OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction

Theorem 1.1 [The three-manifold existence theorem]: Small neck parameters give metrics without conjugate points on a closed connected orientable manifold

A three-manifold excluding nonpositive sectional curvature.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The curvature question concerns all smooth metrics on the same three-manifold. The construction uses two truncated hyperbolic surface products, joined along torus collars, and a family of metrics indexed by a neck parameter δ\delta.

A smooth Riemannian metric gg on a smooth manifold NN is a smooth field of positive definite symmetric bilinear forms on its tangent spaces, with bounded unit balls.✦ A local Riemannian metric gg on an open subset UU of a smooth manifold NN is a smooth field of positive definite symmetric bilinear forms on the tangent spaces of UU, with bounded unit balls.✦ Write 𝒢(N)\mathcal G(N) for the smooth Riemannian metrics on NN.

A positively oriented atlas 𝒜\mathcal A on a smooth three-manifold NN is an atlas whose transition maps have positive Jacobian determinant on every overlap.✦ In a chart cc, let eie_i be the standard coordinate vectors and, for a smooth real-valued function ff in these coordinates, let ∂if=df(ei)\partial_i f=df(e_i). The coordinate metric and its Christoffel symbols are defined by (1), where (gij)=(gij)−1(g^{ij})=(g_{ij})^{-1}. gij(x)=gc−1(x)(d(c−1)xei,d(c−1)xej),Γjki(x)=12∑ℓgiℓ(x)(∂jgℓk(x)+∂kgℓj(x)−∂ℓgjk(x)),Γx(u,v)i=∑j,kΓjki(x)ujvk.\begin{aligned} g_{ij}(x)&=g_{c^{-1}(x)}\bigl(d(c^{-1})_x e_i,d(c^{-1})_x e_j\bigr),\\ \Gamma^i_{jk}(x)&=\frac12\sum_\ell g^{i\ell}(x) \bigl(\partial_jg_{\ell k}(x)+\partial_kg_{\ell j}(x) -\partial_\ell g_{jk}(x)\bigr),\\ \Gamma_x(u,v)^i&=\sum_{j,k}\Gamma^i_{jk}(x)u^jv^k. \end{aligned}(1) The curvature components and curvature operator use the convention in (2). Rℓkij=∂iΓjkℓ−∂jΓikℓ+∑a(ΓiaℓΓjka−ΓjaℓΓika),(Rx(u,v)w)ℓ=∑k,i,jRℓkij(x)wkuivj.\begin{aligned} R^\ell{}_{kij} &=\partial_i\Gamma^\ell_{jk}-\partial_j\Gamma^\ell_{ik} +\sum_a\bigl(\Gamma^\ell_{ia}\Gamma^a_{jk} -\Gamma^\ell_{ja}\Gamma^a_{ik}\bigr),\\ \bigl(R_x(u,v)w\bigr)^\ell &=\sum_{k,i,j}R^\ell{}_{kij}(x)w^ku^iv^j. \end{aligned}(2) The connection term Γx(u,v)∈ℝ3\Gamma_x(u,v)\in\mathbb R^3 is the vector obtained by contracting the Christoffel symbols with the coordinate vectors uu and vv, as in (1).✦

For a coordinate curve x(s)x(s) and a coordinate vector field w(s)w(s) along it, the covariant derivative DswD_sw is the vector field defined by (3).✦ Dsw=w′(s)+Γx(s)(x′(s),w(s)).D_sw=w'(s)+\Gamma_{x(s)}\bigl(x'(s),w(s)\bigr).(3) For a set of times U⊂ℝU\subset\mathbb R and a metric gg on a smooth manifold NN, a geodesic γ:ℝ→N\gamma:\mathbb R\to N on UU is a curve smooth on UU whose covariant acceleration vanishes at every time in UU, in every atlas chart containing the corresponding point of the curve, as in the first equation of (4).✦ For a curve γ:ℝ→N\gamma:\mathbb R\to N and a set of times U⊂ℝU\subset\mathbb R, a Jacobi field JJ along γ\gamma on UU is a field J(s)∈Tγ(s)NJ(s)\in T_{\gamma(s)}N whose coordinates j(s)=dcγ(s)J(s)j(s)=dc_{\gamma(s)}J(s) are smooth on U∩γ−1(dom⁡c)U\cap\gamma^{-1}(\operatorname{dom}c) in every atlas chart cc and satisfy the second equation of (4) there, with x=c∘γx=c\circ\gamma.✦ Dsx′=0,Ds2j+Rx(s)(j,x′)x′=0.D_sx'=0,\qquad D_s^2j+R_{x(s)}\bigl(j,x'\bigr)x'=0.(4) A metric gg on NN has no conjugate points if every Jacobi field along a geodesic on an open interval that vanishes at two distinct times vanishes throughout that interval.✦ A metric gg on a smooth manifold NN has nonpositive sectional curvature if gx(Rx(u,v)v,u)≤0g_x(R_x(u,v)v,u)\le0 for every chart point and every pair of coordinate tangent vectors u,vu,v.✦ Write 𝒢≤0(N)\mathcal G_{\le0}(N) for the set of smooth Riemannian metrics on NN with nonpositive sectional curvature, and write Kg(x,σ)K_g(x,\sigma) for sectional curvature on a tangent two-plane σ⊂TxN\sigma\subset T_xN.

The Surface Products and Their Gluing

Let ℍ\mathbb H be the upper half-plane. The subgroup Γ⊂SL(2,ℤ)\Gamma\subset \mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb Z) is generated by the matrices in (5), acting on ℍ\mathbb H by fractional linear transformations. The effective action group Γeff\Gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} of Γ\Gamma on ℍ\mathbb H is the image of Γ\Gamma in the permutations of ℍ\mathbb H.✦ The surface Σ=ℍ/Γ\Sigma=\mathbb H/\Gamma is the orbit quotient, with projection π:ℍ→Σ\pi:\mathbb H\to\Sigma. ϕ=(1112),ψ=(1−1−12),−Id.\phi=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\1&2\end{pmatrix},\qquad \psi=\begin{pmatrix}1&-1\\-1&2\end{pmatrix},\qquad -\mathrm{Id}.(5) The first matrix in (5) is the hyperbolic generator ϕ∈SL(2,ℤ)\phi\in\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb Z).✦ The second matrix in (5) is the hyperbolic generator ψ∈SL(2,ℤ)\psi\in\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb Z).✦

The height hΣh_\Sigma on Σ\Sigma is the real-valued function given by the logarithm of the maximal imaginary part in each orbit.✦ For a truncation level aa, the open truncated surface Σa\Sigma_a and the cusp CaC_a are the subsets in (6). hΣ([z])=log⁡(maxγ∈ΓIm(γz)),Σa={q∈Σ:hΣ(q)<log⁡a},Ca=π{z∈ℍ:Im⁡z>a}.\begin{aligned} h_\Sigma([z])&=\log\!\left(\max_{\gamma\in\Gamma} \operatorname{Im}(\gamma z)\right),\\ \Sigma_a&=\{q\in\Sigma:h_\Sigma(q)<\log a\},\qquad C_a=\pi\{z\in\mathbb H:\operatorname{Im}z>a\}. \end{aligned}(6) Let C=ℝ/6ℤC=\mathbb R/6\mathbb Z and T2=C×CT^2=C\times C. For a>1a>1, the cusp coordinates identify CaC_a with (a,∞)×C(a,\infty)\times C through the imaginary part and the real part modulo 66.✦ Their product with the remaining circle gives coordinates (r,x,y)(r,x,y) on Ca×CC_a\times C.✦ The height cylinder above aa is (a,∞)×T2(a,\infty)\times T^2.✦ The horoball cylinder projection sends z∈ℍz\in\mathbb H with Im⁡z>a\operatorname{Im}z>a to (Im⁡z,[Re⁡z])∈(a,∞)×C(\operatorname{Im}z,[\operatorname{Re}z])\in(a,\infty)\times C.✦

The full product piece is W=Σ×CW=\Sigma\times C, and the truncated piece is X=Σ8×CX=\Sigma_8\times C. The collar OO of the truncated piece XX is the subset O=C2×C⊂XO=C_2\times C\subset X, with coordinates (r,x,y)∈(2,8)×T2(r,x,y)\in(2,8)\times T^2. The torus automorphism 𝒯\mathscr T and the collar identification are given by (7). The glued manifold MM is the space obtained from two copies of XX by this identification; denote their canonical inclusions by ι−\iota_- and ι+\iota_+. 𝒯(x,y)=(x+y,x),(r,x,y)−∼(16/r,𝒯−1(x,y))+=(16/r,y,x−y)+.\mathscr T(x,y)=(x+y,x),\qquad (r,x,y)_-\sim\bigl(16/r,\mathscr T^{-1}(x,y)\bigr)_+ =(16/r,y,x-y)_+.(7) The radial inversion of the collar interval (2,8)(2,8) is the self-inverse homeomorphism r↦16/rr\mapsto16/r.

The Metric Family

The Euclidean metric gEg_E on a real inner product space VV is the bilinear form given by its ordinary inner product.✦ The hyperbolic metric gℍg_{\mathbb H} on ℍ\mathbb H is the restriction of the Euclidean metric, scaled by (Im⁡z)−2(\operatorname{Im}z)^{-2}, and equals (dx2+dy2)/y2(dx^2+dy^2)/y^2.✦ The hyperbolic surface metric gΣg_\Sigma on Σ\Sigma is the metric obtained by descent of the hyperbolic metric on ℍ\mathbb H.✦ For a real period bb, the flat circle metric on ℝ/bℤ\mathbb R/b\mathbb Z is the descent of the Euclidean metric on ℝ\mathbb R under translations by bℤb\mathbb Z.✦

For a smooth map f:N→N′f:N\to N' with invertible differential and a metric gg on N′N', the pullback metric f*gf^*g on NN is the metric defined by (8).✦ The Riemannian product g⊕hg\oplus h on N×N′N\times N' of metrics gg on NN and hh on N′N' and, for a smooth nowhere zero function r:N→ℝr:N\to\mathbb R, the scaled metric r2gr^2g on NN are the metrics given by (8). (f*g)x(u,v)=gf(x)(dfxu,dfxv),(g⊕h)(x,y)((u1,u2),(v1,v2))=gx(u1,v1)+hy(u2,v2),(r2g)x(u,v)=r(x)2gx(u,v).\begin{aligned} (f^*g)_x(u,v)&=g_{f(x)}(df_xu,df_xv),\\ (g\oplus h)_{(x,y)}\bigl((u_1,u_2),(v_1,v_2)\bigr) &=g_x(u_1,v_1)+h_y(u_2,v_2),\\ (r^2g)_x(u,v)&=r(x)^2g_x(u,v). \end{aligned}(8) Restriction to an open subset is pullback by its inclusion.✦ A descended metric gQg_Q on a covering quotient QQ is the metric obtained by pulling back the invariant covering metric by a local inverse of the covering projection.✦ A glued metric gg on a smooth manifold NN with a specified open cover is the metric whose restrictions to that cover are the specified agreeing local metrics.✦ For a constant c≠0c\ne0, the core product metric on WW is gΣ+c2dθ2g_\Sigma+c^2d\theta^2.✦

A smooth invertible moving frame FxF_x on a real vector space VV determines the metric gxg_x on VV given by gx(u,v)=⟨Fxu,Fxv⟩g_x(u,v)=\langle F_xu,F_xv\rangle.✦ In coordinates (t,x,y)(t,x,y), with height coordinate tt, the triangular frame and its metric are given in (9), for smooth functions α,β,η\alpha,\beta,\eta with αβ≠0\alpha\beta\ne0. Fx(vt,vx,vy)=(vt,α(x)(vx−η(x)vy),β(x)vy),g=dt2+α2(dx−ηdy)2+β2dy2.\begin{aligned} F_x(v_t,v_x,v_y)&= \bigl(v_t,\alpha(x)(v_x-\eta(x)v_y),\beta(x)v_y\bigr),\\ g&=dt^2+\alpha^2(dx-\eta\,dy)^2+\beta^2dy^2. \end{aligned}(9) When the coefficients depend only on tt, this metric descends from ℝ×ℝ2\mathbb R\times\mathbb R^2 to the torus cylinder ℝ×T2\mathbb R\times T^2. Its covering projection is (t,x,y)↦(t,[x],[y])(t,x,y)\mapsto(t,[x],[y]), with deck translations in 6ℤ×6ℤ6\mathbb Z\times6\mathbb Z on the last two coordinates.

For a continuous bilinear form qq on a real vector space WW and a continuous linear map A:V→WA:V\to W, the pullback bilinear form A*qA^*q on VV is given by (A*q)(u,v)=q(Au,Av)(A^*q)(u,v)=q(Au,Av).✦

Let Θ\Theta be the smooth transition function. The one-sided cutoff aa, its integral AA, the collar transition λ\lambda, and the shear transition χ\chi are the functions in (10). a(t)={exp⁡(−1/(2/3−t)),t<2/3,0,t≥2/3,A(t)=∫0ta(u)du,λ(t)=Θ(2t+3/2),χ(t)=Θ(6(t−5/12)).\begin{aligned} a(t)&=\begin{cases} \exp\bigl(-1/(2/3-t)\bigr),&t<2/3,\\ 0,&t\ge2/3, \end{cases} & A(t)&=\int_0^t a(u)\,du,\\ \lambda(t)&=\Theta(2t+3/2), &\chi(t)&=\Theta\bigl(6(t-5/12)\bigr). \end{aligned}(10) For 0<δ≤1/20<\delta\le1/2, the collar denominator dδd_\delta, terminal decay rate bδb_\delta, logarithmic decay kδk_\delta, and warping function ℓδ\ell_\delta are defined by (11). dδ(t)=1+δA(t),bδ(t)=δa(t)2dδ(t),kδ(t)=1−λ(t)+λ(t)bδ(t),ℓδ(t)=exp⁡(−∫0tkδ(u)du).\begin{aligned} d_\delta(t)&=1+\delta A(t),& b_\delta(t)&=\frac{\delta a(t)}{2d_\delta(t)},\\ k_\delta(t)&=1-\lambda(t)+\lambda(t)b_\delta(t),& \ell_\delta(t)&=\exp\!\left(-\int_0^t k_\delta(u)\,du\right). \end{aligned}(11) The matching period BδB_\delta and circle scales c−,c+c_-,c_+ are constants, and the neck radii r1,r2r_1,r_2 are functions of the height tt, given by (12). The neck metric gneck,δg_{\mathrm{neck},\delta} is the quotient cylinder metric of (9) with α=r1\alpha=r_1, β=r2\beta=r_2, and η=χ\eta=\chi.✦ Bδ=6e4ℓδ(−1),r1(t)=δ2Bδ6ℓδ(t),r2(t)=Bδ6ℓδ(1−t),c−=Bδ6ℓδ(1),c+=δ2c−.\begin{aligned} B_\delta&=\frac6{e^4\ell_\delta(-1)},\\ r_1(t)&=\frac{\delta^2B_\delta}{6}\ell_\delta(t),& r_2(t)&=\frac{B_\delta}{6}\ell_\delta(1-t),\\ c_-&=\frac{B_\delta}{6}\ell_\delta(1),&c_+&=\delta^2c_-. \end{aligned}(12)

For a real parameter Λ\Lambda, the radial coordinate profile ρΛ\rho_\Lambda and the radial cylinder map RΛR_\Lambda are defined by (13); the same formula on ℝ×ℝ2\mathbb R\times\mathbb R^2 defines the lift of RΛR_\Lambda. ζ(t)=Θ(4t−1),ρΛ(t)=(1−ζ(t))(t−Λ−1)+ζ(t)t−log⁡2log⁡4,RΛ(t,x,y)=(ρΛ(t),x,y).\begin{aligned} \zeta(t)&=\Theta(4t-1),\\ \rho_\Lambda(t)&=(1-\zeta(t))(t-\Lambda-1) +\zeta(t)\frac{t-\log2}{\log4},\\ R_\Lambda(t,x,y)&=(\rho_\Lambda(t),x,y). \end{aligned}(13) The reversing cylinder map is ℛ(t,x,y)=(1−t,𝒯(x,y))\mathscr R(t,x,y)=(1-t,\mathscr T(x,y)).✦ The left and right cylinder metrics are the pullbacks in (14). h−=R4−2log⁡δ*gneck,δ,h+=R4*ℛ*gneck,δ.h_-=R_{4-2\log\delta}^*g_{\mathrm{neck},\delta},\qquad h_+=R_4^*\mathscr R^*g_{\mathrm{neck},\delta}.(14) The radial transition function ζ:ℝ→ℝ\zeta:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R is the smooth transition evaluated at 4t−14t-1, as in (13). The height reflection is the self-inverse homeomorphism of ℝ\mathbb R given by t↦1−tt\mapsto1-t. For a metric hh on the torus cylinder, the switched cylinder metric is the pullback ℛ*h\mathscr R^*h by the reversing cylinder map. For Λ≥4\Lambda\ge4 and a metric hh on the torus cylinder, its radially pulled back metric is RΛ*hR_\Lambda^*h.

On each copy of WW, the full piece metric is the gluing of the core product metric with circle scale c±c_\pm on {hΣ<1/4}×C\{h_\Sigma<1/4\}\times C and the cylinder metric h±h_\pm on Ce1/8×CC_{e^{1/8}}\times C, using the product cusp coordinates and t=log⁡rt=\log r.✦ Restricting these metrics to XX gives the two piece metrics.✦ Their gluing through ι−\iota_- and ι+\iota_+ defines gδg_\delta on MM, expressed in real three-dimensional coordinates. The core region is the open subset {hΣ<1/4}×C\{h_\Sigma<1/4\}\times C of WW. The cusp threshold is e1/8e^{1/8}.

The Claim

Theorem 1. There exist a closed connected orientable smooth three-manifold NN and a metric g∈𝒢(N)g\in\mathcal G(N) satisfying (15). (N,g) has no conjugate points,𝒢≤0(N)=⌀.\text{$(N,g)$ has no conjugate points},\qquad \mathcal G_{\le0}(N)=\varnothing.(15)✦ For the family gδg_\delta on the glued manifold MM, there is a number 0<δ0≤1/20<\delta_0\le1/2 such that (16) holds whenever 0<δ≤δ00<\delta\le\delta_0. (M,gδ) has no conjugate points.\text{$(M,g_\delta)$ has no conjugate points}.(16)✦ For each h∈𝒢(M)h\in\mathcal G(M), there are a point x∈Mx\in M and a tangent two-plane σ⊂TxM\sigma\subset T_xM satisfying (17). Kh(x,σ)>0.K_h(x,\sigma)>0.(17)✦

What Is Checked

The existence assertion (15) is stated over Hausdorff second countable compact connected smooth three-manifolds with positively oriented atlases. The assertions (16) and (17) concern the glued manifold MM and its smooth metrics in real coordinates. The uniform assertion is stated over the family gδg_\delta with 0<δ≤1/20<\delta\le1/2.

The circle and cylinder projections are smooth covering maps, and their deck translations are smooth isometries of the covering metrics. The effective surface action is smooth✦ and preserves the hyperbolic metric✦; the surface projection is a smooth covering map. For a>1a>1, the horoball quotient projection and the map z↦(Im⁡z,[Re⁡z])z\mapsto(\operatorname{Im}z,[\operatorname{Re}z]) have the same fibers.✦ The truncated surface domains are open✦, and Σ8\Sigma_8 is nonempty.✦ The product cusp above each level a>1a>1 is nonempty.✦ The circle, cylinder, and surface projections have smooth local inverses.

The Euclidean bilinear field and the pullback inner products are smooth. Descent and gluing give smooth positive definite symmetric forms with bounded unit balls. The shear cutoff and triangular frame are smooth. The reversing cylinder map is a diffeomorphism. The inclusion of the upper half-plane into ℂ\mathbb C is smooth.✦ A smooth moving frame gives a smoothly varying metric bilinear form.✦

The radial maps and their lifts are smooth and commute with the cylinder projection.✦ For Λ≥4\Lambda\ge4, the radial slope is positive✦, and the lift’s differential is diag⁡(ρΛ′(t),1,1)\operatorname{diag}(\rho_\Lambda'(t),1,1).✦ The left neck length satisfies 4−2log⁡δ≥44-2\log\delta\ge4 for 0<δ≤1/20<\delta\le1/2✦, and the matching period BδB_\delta is positive.✦ The logarithmic cylinder coordinates and their exponential inverses are smooth. The product cusp charts and the truncated piece inclusion are smooth with invertible differentials. For a nonzero real number aa, the radial linear dilation of ℝ×ℝ2\mathbb R\times\mathbb R^2 is the linear automorphism (vt,vx,vy)↦(avt,vx,vy)(v_t,v_x,v_y)\mapsto(av_t,v_x,v_y); its inverse divides the height component by aa.

The cylinder cusp formulas are (18), valid on the covering space for t<1/4t<1/4. h±=dt2+e−2tdx2+c±2dy2.h_\pm=dt^2+e^{-2t}dx^2+c_\pm^2dy^2.(18) The core and cusp local metrics agree on their overlap✦, and their domains cover WW.✦ The inverse piece charts are smooth✦ and cover MM✦; the two piece metrics agree after pullback to every chart overlap.✦