OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Reducing the rank of a surface diagram

§5.2 (proof of Proposition 5.1): producing a marked band cut: For a proper diagram with finite vertices and a maximal-rank parent of positive genus

A surface solution produces a marked cut.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

A marked band cut replaces a selected seam of a surface diagram by a band and its mirror, with separate facet labels for the new connected strips. The input is a solution in transport matrices and a chosen boundary occurrence on the parent facet. The boundary marking includes the old circles and the circles created by the cut.

Let DD be a surface diagram with facets FF, seams SS, vertices VV, and ordered seam arities νs\nu_s. Its ordered port assembly attaches the local ports at vertices bijectively to seam ends, preserving their orientations and child orders. Local vertices are passages, allowing continuation or adjacent interchange, and splittings or their reversed merges.✦ Corner pairings preserve facet labels. Write fsf_s for the parent facet of ss, fs,if_{s,i} for its child at position 0≤i<νs0\leq i<\nu_s, and rfr_f for a facet rank. Distinct occurrences remain distinct when their facet labels agree. The rank condition is (1). rfs=∑i=0νs−1rfs,i.r_{f_s}=\sum_{i=0}^{\nu_s-1}r_{f_{s,i}}.(1) A side occurrence consists of a seam and either its parent side or one of its ordered child positions. A side germ is an endpoint of a particular side occurrence. The positive boundary orientation follows the seam orientation on a parent side and opposes it on a child side. At a splitting the ordered children before the split are a prefix, a single middle child and a suffix; after the split they are the same prefix, the ordered subblocks and the same suffix, while the branch has exactly those ordered subblocks. At a splitting, corners pair the before and after parents, the corresponding prefix and suffix children, the before middle child with the branch parent, and each after subblock with the corresponding branch child.

A facet ff has genus gfg_f and an ordered list of boundary circles bb, each with a positive length ℓf,b\ell_{f,b}. The boundary enumeration af,b,ia_{f,b,i} is a bijection from all boundary positions to side occurrences, following the corner successor cyclically. A proper surface diagram DD is a surface diagram whose facet ranks are all positive and whose seams each have at least two children.✦

Fix a commutative ring RR and a field KK with an RR-algebra structure. Scalar puncture data PP assign a finite list of units λf,j∈R×\lambda_{f,j}\in R^\times to each facet.✦ A transport family zz on DD assigns a matrix in the appropriate general linear group to each side occurrence, a frame to each seam end, and two matrices to each handle. For a family zz, write ps(z)p_s(z) and cs,i(z)c_{s,i}(z) for parent and child transports, Fs0(z),Fs1(z)F_s^0(z),F_s^1(z) for seam frames, and Hf,k0(z),Hf,k1(z)H_{f,k}^0(z),H_{f,k}^1(z) for handles. A port frame for a transport family on DD is the isomorphism from the ordered child sum to the parent fiber at a seam end.✦

Identified Flags and Solutions

For a coordinate grading a:I→ℕa:I\to\mathbb N and a frame e:KI≃We:K^I\simeq W, the framed prefix and framed grade map are defined by (2). The grading is zero-based; the named module of grade kk is Mk=Ka−1(k)M_k=K^{a^{-1}(k)}. Wk(e)=e{u∈KI:ui=0 whenever a(i)≥k},gr⁡k(e)(v)=(e−1v)|a−1(k),Wk+1(e)/Wk(e)≃Mk.\begin{aligned} W_k(e)&=e\{u\in K^I:u_i=0\text{ whenever }a(i)\geq k\},\\ \operatorname{gr}_k(e)(v)&=(e^{-1}v)|_{a^{-1}(k)}, &W_{k+1}(e)/W_k(e)&\simeq M_k. \end{aligned}(2) For a coordinate grading a:I→ℕa:I\to\mathbb N, two frames e,e′:KI≃We,e':K^I\simeq W have the same identified flag, denoted Φa(e,e′)\Phi_a(e,e'), when (3) holds, including equality of the quotient identifications. Φa(e,e′)⇔{Wk(e)=Wk(e′)for every k,gr⁡k(e)|Wk+1(e)=gr⁡k(e′)|Wk+1(e)for every k.\Phi_a(e,e')\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad \begin{cases} W_k(e)=W_k(e')&\text{for every }k,\\ \operatorname{gr}_k(e)|_{W_{k+1}(e)} =\operatorname{gr}_k(e')|_{W_{k+1}(e)}&\text{for every }k. \end{cases}(3)✦ The coordinate filtration prefix at level kk is the subspace of KIK^I whose coordinates of grade at least kk vanish.✦ The coordinate grade projection at level kk is the linear map from KIK^I to MkM_k that restricts a vector to its coordinates of grade kk.✦

The seam grading asa_s assigns to a coordinate its ordered child position, with named grade module Krfs,iK^{r_{f_{s,i}}}.✦ The framed seam equation 𝒮s(z)\mathcal S_s(z) is (4), where matrices act as linear frames. 𝒮s(z):=Φas(ps(z)Fs0(z),Fs1(z)⨁i=0νs−1cs,i(z)−1).\mathcal S_s(z):=\Phi_{a_s}\left( p_s(z)F_s^0(z),\; F_s^1(z)\bigoplus_{i=0}^{\nu_s-1}c_{s,i}(z)^{-1}\right).(4)✦ Vertex flag compatibility 𝒱D(z)\mathcal V_D(z) for a transport family zz on DD is the condition that the permitted flag comparison holds at every vertex. A continuation compares the full ordered flags; an adjacent interchange compares the flag with the interchanged pair combined into one named direct sum.✦ A splitting compares the after frame with the before frame refined in its middle block by the branch frame, retaining the prefix and suffix quotient maps.✦ A reversed merge uses the same comparison in the forward splitting direction. The induced local occurrence ranks at a vertex assign to each parent and child occurrence the rank of its facet; paired corners have equal ranks, and each parent rank is the sum of its child ranks. The framed parent transport at a seam is its parent transport composed with its initial seam frame. The framed inverse child transport is the terminal seam frame composed with the ordered direct sum of the inverse child transports.

The boundary monodromy Bf,b(z)B_{f,b}(z) is the reverse ordered product of the side matrices z(af,b,i)z(a_{f,b,i}).✦ A solution z∈Sol⁡(D,P;K)z\in\operatorname{Sol}(D,P;K) is a transport family satisfying (5); the images of the puncture units in KK are understood. (∏k=0gf−1[Hf,k0(z),Hf,k1(z)])(∏bBf,b(z))=(∏jλf,j)−1Irf(f∈F),𝒮s(z)(s∈S),𝒱D(z),[A,B]=ABA−1B−1.\begin{gathered} \left(\prod_{k=0}^{g_f-1} [H_{f,k}^0(z),H_{f,k}^1(z)]\right) \left(\prod_b B_{f,b}(z)\right) =\left(\prod_j\lambda_{f,j}\right)^{-1}I_{r_f} \quad(f\in F),\\ \mathcal S_s(z)\quad(s\in S),\qquad \mathcal V_D(z), \qquad [A,B]=ABA^{-1}B^{-1}. \end{gathered}(5)✦ The surface relation word of a facet is the ordered product of its handle commutators followed by the ordered product of its boundary monodromy words. The scalar surface target is the inverse product of the prescribed puncture scalars times the identity matrix in the facet rank.

The Band and Its Marking

Fix a seam qq, put p=fqp=f_q, r=rpr=r_p, n=νqn=\nu_q, and si=rfq,is_i=r_{f_{q,i}}. A rank array dd and its common graded atoms are the data in (6); cells of rank zero remain in the array and contribute no atoms. Row, column, and cell labels are separate, with an independent principal parent. d=(dij)0≤i,j<n,0≤dij≤r,∑i,jdij=r,Ad={(i,j,u):0≤u<dij},rrow(i)=∑jdij,rcol(j)=∑idij,rcell(i,j)=dij.\begin{gathered} d=(d_{ij})_{0\leq i,j<n},\qquad 0\leq d_{ij}\leq r, \qquad\sum_{i,j}d_{ij}=r,\\ A_d=\{(i,j,u):0\leq u<d_{ij}\},\qquad r_{\mathrm{row}(i)}=\sum_jd_{ij},\quad r_{\mathrm{col}(j)}=\sum_id_{ij},\quad r_{\mathrm{cell}(i,j)}=d_{ij}. \end{gathered}(6)

For frames f,h:⨁iKsi≃Krf,h:\bigoplus_iK^{s_i}\simeq K^r, a named simultaneous splitting w=(d,e,ρ,κ)w=(d,e,\rho,\kappa) consists of an atom frame e:KAd≃Kre:K^{A_d}\simeq K^r and isomorphisms from its row and column grade modules to the named modules Mk=KskM_k=K^{s_k}, with Mk=0M_k=0 outside 0≤k<n0\leq k<n. Its conditions are (7), where WkrowW_k^{\mathrm{row}} and WkcolW_k^{\mathrm{col}} use the row and column indices of atoms as their gradings. Wkrow(e)=Wk(f),Wkcol(e)=Wk(h),ρkgr⁡krow(e)(v)=gr⁡k(f)(v)(v∈Wk+1row(e)),κkgr⁡kcol(e)(v)=gr⁡k(h)(v)(v∈Wk+1col(e)).\begin{aligned} W_k^{\mathrm{row}}(e)&=W_k(f),& W_k^{\mathrm{col}}(e)&=W_k(h),\\ \rho_k\operatorname{gr}^{\mathrm{row}}_k(e)(v)&=\operatorname{gr}_k(f)(v) &&(v\in W_{k+1}^{\mathrm{row}}(e)),\\ \kappa_k\operatorname{gr}^{\mathrm{col}}_k(e)(v)&=\operatorname{gr}_k(h)(v) &&(v\in W_{k+1}^{\mathrm{col}}(e)). \end{aligned}(7)✦

The atomic band ℬ(d)\mathcal B(d) is the decorated band of a chosen ranked gallery from the ordered row list to the ordered column list, where a gallery with a fixed parent facet is a finite sequence, possibly empty, of decorated passages, splittings and reversed merges, with matching ordered facet lists at adjacent main ports and every branch port retained. The parent contains all atoms, and row, column, and cell facets contain the atoms with the corresponding indices.✦ At a vertex these sets give a local atom decomposition: paired germs have the same set, and the child sets partition the parent set.✦ Its port matrices identify the ordered child atom bases with the parent atom basis.✦ Corner-coherent bases are changes of basis agreeing across paired germs.✦ The frame ee and the named maps ρ,κ\rho,\kappa give the principal, row, and column changes of basis for these matrices. The port frame in corner-coherent bases is obtained by first applying the inverse ordered child basis change, then the original port frame, and then the parent basis change.✦

A lower corner of a band vertex is an initial boundary germ other than the outgoing parent germ.✦ The strip forest joins the corresponding lower corners at successive vertices along each internal child occurrence, with at most one incoming and one outgoing edge at a node; the root of a component is the node reached by following its edges backwards until none enters.

For a proper diagram whose selected parent has maximal rank, and an array dd of total rank rr whose row and column ranks are both sis_i, write ℳq(d)\mathcal M_q(d) for the refined marked diagram obtained by grafting the band and its mirror at qq.✦ Its facets are the old facets together with fresh strip components that meet neither endpoint child list.✦ Components meeting an endpoint receive that child’s old facet label, in its specified position. Old ranks are retained, and a fresh strip has the rank of its atomic facet.✦ The genus of pp is reduced by one, the other old genera are retained, and fresh genera are zero.✦ The marked boundary circles retain the order and starting occurrence of every old circle, append one mirror circle on pp, and give each fresh strip one circle; their lengths and cyclic enumerations come from the actual grafted boundary cycles. The mirror circle starts at its position zero, traversing the mirrored principal sides in reverse vertex order, and a fresh strip circle starts at the original strip side of its root. Let PdP_d be the scalar puncture data on ℳq(d)\mathcal M_q(d) that retain the old punctures and assign no punctures to fresh strips.✦ An old circle containing the parent side of qq becomes the extended principal circle by adjoining all original principal sides of the band.✦ For every other old circle, the attached secondary circle is obtained by processing the initial input contacts in child order and then the final output contacts in child order, adjoining a contact strip cycle precisely when its old child side belongs to the current circle.✦

The doubled band patch joins the band to its mirror, sewing both copies of the internal seams and every boundary interface except the first input and last output interfaces.✦ It leaves two positive and two negative short ends, and the doubled closed wiring pairs the remaining short ends with the same interface labels.

The strip refined band retains the atomic band’s vertices and their types, assigns each contacted strip its specified old child facet, and gives each uncontacted strip its own fresh facet label.✦ Its two endpoint lists are the old children of the selected seam in their specified order.

The inverse handle cut diagram divides every old seam into three successive pieces, inserts two continuation vertices on every seam other than qq and two oppositely oriented splitting vertices at qq, and joins the latter by a transverse seam of arity one whose two sides lie on pp.✦ It retains the old facets and ranks, decreases a positive genus of pp by one while leaving genus zero fixed, retains the other genera, triples every old boundary length, and appends a two-sided boundary circle on pp.

The unmarked refined cut diagram has the same refined graft, facet ranks and genera as the marked diagram, with boundary circles given by the cycles of the actual boundary successor.✦

For a family gg, matrices J,T∈GLr(K)J,T\in\mathrm{GL}_r(K), and a splitting ww of Fq0(g)F_q^0(g) and J−1pq(g)Fq0(g)J^{-1}p_q(g)F_q^0(g), let ℱq(g,w,T)\mathcal F_q(g,w,T) be the cut port frames. They use the old port frames, the atom frames with their corner-coherent bases on the band, and the mirrored frames determined by TT. For a matrix Y∈GLr(K)Y\in\mathrm{GL}_r(K), let Σq(g,J,Y)\Sigma_q(g,J,Y) be the refined cut side family, obtained by replacing the old parent side value at qq by JJ and grafting the new short side values: every child side and the original principal short side receive the identity, while the mirror principal short side receives YY.✦ The marked generator family in (8) assigns these port frames, side values, and a chosen handle family η\eta to their respective generators. Y=T−1J−1pq(g)T,Zq(g,J,T,w;η)=values⁡(ℱq(g,w,T),Σq(g,J,Y),η).\begin{aligned} Y&=T^{-1}J^{-1}p_q(g)T,\\ Z_q(g,J,T,w;\eta)&= \operatorname{values}\bigl(\mathcal F_q(g,w,T),\Sigma_q(g,J,Y),\eta\bigr). \end{aligned}(8) The mirror facet gauges change the principal fiber by TT and retain the named gauges on every lower fiber.✦

The Chosen Transports

For x∈Sol⁡(D,P;K)x\in\operatorname{Sol}(D,P;K) with gp>0g_p>0, let t,at,a be the two matrices of the last handle of pp. Choose a boundary circle b0b_0 of pp and a position i0i_0 on that circle. The ordered boundary gauges are (9). U=t−1[t,a],V=t−1a−1Bp,b0(x),Gf,b={Uf=p,b<b0,Vf=p,b>b0,Iotherwise.\begin{gathered} U=t^{-1}[t,a],\qquad V=t^{-1}a^{-1}B_{p,b_0}(x),\\ G_{f,b}=\begin{cases} U&f=p,\ b<b_0,\\ V&f=p,\ b>b_0,\\ I&\text{otherwise}. \end{cases} \end{gathered}(9) Let g=xGg=x^G be the boundary gauge transform: each side is conjugated by its circle gauge, each seam frame is multiplied by the parent circle gauge on the left and the inverse ordered sum of child circle gauges on the right, and handles retain their values.✦

Put ui=g(ap,b0,i)u_i=g(a_{p,b_0,i}). The boundary prefix α\alpha, tail β\beta, and chosen transports J,TJ,T are defined by (10), with an empty product equal to the identity. α=ui0−1⋯u0,β=uℓp,b0−1⋯ui0+1,J=β−1aα−1,T=αt.\alpha=u_{i_0-1}\cdots u_0,\qquad \beta=u_{\ell_{p,b_0}-1}\cdots u_{i_0+1},\qquad J=\beta^{-1}a\alpha^{-1},\qquad T=\alpha t.(10) Choose the named simultaneous splitting ww of Fq0(g)F_q^0(g) and J−1pq(g)Fq0(g)J^{-1}p_q(g)F_q^0(g), and denote its rank array by dd. Let ηt\eta_t be the retained handle family: remove the last handle of pp, conjugate its remaining handle matrices by t−1t^{-1}, and retain the handle matrices on every other old facet.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let DD be proper with finite vertex set. Suppose rf≤rpr_f\leq r_p for every facet ff, where p=fqp=f_q. Let g̃\widetilde g be a transport family satisfying the old seam equations, let J̃,T̃∈GLr(K)\widetilde J,\widetilde T\in\mathrm{GL}_r(K), and let w̃\widetilde w be a named splitting of Fq0(g̃)F_q^0(\widetilde g) and J̃−1pq(g̃)Fq0(g̃)\widetilde J^{-1}p_q(\widetilde g)F_q^0(\widetilde g). Write d̃\widetilde d for the array of w̃\widetilde w, and let η\eta range over handle families on ℳq(d̃)\mathcal M_q(\widetilde d). Then the marked seam lift satisfies (11). 𝒮s(Zq(g̃,J̃,T̃,w̃;η))for every η and every seam s of ℳq(d̃).\mathcal S_s\bigl(Z_q(\widetilde g,\widetilde J,\widetilde T, \widetilde w;\eta)\bigr) \quad\text{for every }\eta\text{ and every seam }s \text{ of }\mathcal M_q(\widetilde d).(11)✦

Suppose also that gp>0g_p>0. Let PP be scalar puncture data, let x∈Sol⁡(D,P;K)x\in\operatorname{Sol}(D,P;K), and choose b0,i0b_0,i_0 on pp. With the chosen transports and splitting above, the produced marked diagram is (12) and its generator values are (13). D♯:=ℳq(d).D^{\sharp}:=\mathcal M_q(d).(12)✦ v:=Zq(g,J,T,w;ηt).v:=Z_q(g,J,T,w;\eta_t).(13)✦ They satisfy vertex flag compatibility✦. 𝒮s(v)for every seam s of D♯.\mathcal S_s(v)\qquad\text{for every seam }s\text{ of }D^{\sharp}.(14)✦ If the chosen boundary occurrence is the parent side of qq, so that ap,b0,i0=(q,parent)a_{p,b_0,i_0}=(q,\mathrm{parent}), the produced marked solution is (15), with P♯=PdP^{\sharp}=P_d. x♯:=v∈Sol⁡(D♯,P♯;K).x^{\sharp}:=v\ \in\operatorname{Sol}(D^{\sharp},P^{\sharp};K).(15)✦

In the paper, the result reads: transporting the two endpoint flags of an old solution into a chosen band gives one of finitely many intersection rank arrays dd, and a simultaneous splitting gives two-flag sequences and lower-rank strips matched by the old band transport, with cut data forming a solution that reconstructs the old one; this is performed along disjoint arcs cutting all nonclosed maximal-rank facets to disks, and arbitrary old solutions are recovered through matching choices.

What Is Checked

The statements concern transport matrices over an RR-field KK, scalar punctures, and the ordered incidence and boundary data of a proper diagram with finite vertices and a maximal-rank parent of positive genus; the full solution statement also identifies the chosen boundary occurrence with that parent side.

Named simultaneous splittings exist for the two frames✦, and their row and column ranks both equal the prescribed child ranks sis_i. The atomic gallery conserves every atom and has no repeated ordered pair of crossing facet labels. The refined graft satisfies the seam rank sum.✦ The preliminary facet extension retains the old incidence, ranks, genera and boundary markings, and adds fresh strip labels with their refined ranks, genus zero and no boundary circles; under properness and maximality its selected parent is no seam child.✦ The marked boundary circles of the refined graft are disjoint cycles covering all side occurrences, and their enumerations follow the boundary successor.✦ Distinct initial row and final column child occurrences meet distinct doubled strips, even when their old facet labels agree. At each original band vertex, the atom fiber dimensions agree with the local occurrence ranks induced by the marked diagram. The same agreement holds at each mirror band vertex for the mirrored atom fiber dimensions.