OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §4. A matrix-cone homomorphism with a full corner

4.5 Selfadjoint tensor elements linearly independent in representations: Under every unital **-homomorphism to a nonzero unital C*C^*-algebra, producing finite families in factor and scalar-commutant maximal tensor representations

Finite-dimensional selfadjoint subspaces with noncommuting images yield linear independence.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Take a unital complex C*C^*-algebra DD and a finite-dimensional real subspace VV of selfadjoint elements of DD such that every unital **-homomorphism from DD into a nonzero unital complex C*C^*-algebra sends some two elements of VV to noncommuting elements. How does this noncommutativity yield arbitrarily many elements in some finite tensor power whose images remain ℂ\mathbb{C}-linearly independent under commuting Hilbert-space representations?

Definitions

For a complex Hilbert space HH, write B(H)B(H) for the unital complex C*C^*-algebra of bounded linear operators on HH, with identity operator 11. A factor von Neumann algebra MM on HH is a von Neumann algebra on HH such that every operator T∈B(H)T \in B(H) belonging to both MM and its commutant M′M' equals z1z 1 for some z∈ℂz \in \mathbb{C}.

Writing ⊗max\otimes_{\max} for the maximal tensor product of unital complex C*C^*-algebras, for any unital complex C*C^*-algebra DD the maximal tensor power sequence (D⊗max(n+1))n≥0(D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+1)})_{n \ge 0} is the sequence of unital complex C*C^*-algebras defined recursively by D⊗max1=D,D⊗max(n+2)=D⊗maxD⊗max(n+1)(n≥0),D^{\otimes_{\max} 1} = D, \qquad D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+2)} = D \otimes_{\max} D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+1)} \qquad (n \ge 0),(1)✦ so that D⊗max(n+1)D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+1)} is the right-nested (n+1)(n+1)-fold maximal tensor power of DD.

Given an integer n≥0n \ge 0, real vector spaces V1,…,VnV_1, \dots, V_n, a unital associative real algebra AA, and a family f=(f1,…,fn)f = (f_1, \dots, f_n) of ℝ\mathbb{R}-linear maps fi:Vi→Af_i \colon V_i \to A (1≤i≤n1 \le i \le n), the tensor multiplication map mf:⨂ℝ,i=1nVi→Am_f \colon \bigotimes_{\mathbb{R},\, i=1}^n V_i \to A is the ℝ\mathbb{R}-linear map satisfying mf(v1⊗⋯⊗vn)=f1(v1)⋯fn(vn)m_f(v_1 \otimes \cdots \otimes v_n) = f_1(v_1) \cdots f_n(v_n)(2)✦ for all vi∈Viv_i \in V_i (1≤i≤n1 \le i \le n), mapping the empty tensor to the unit of AA when n=0n = 0. For a real vector space WW and an integer n≥0n \ge 0, the nn-fold real tensor power ⨂ℝ,i=1nW\bigotimes_{\mathbb{R},\, i=1}^n W is denoted W⊗ℝnW^{\otimes_{\mathbb{R}} n}.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let DD be a unital complex C*C^*-algebra, and let V⊆DV \subseteq D be a finite-dimensional real subspace of selfadjoint elements such that for every nonzero unital complex C*C^*-algebra EE and every unital **-homomorphism θ:D→E\theta \colon D \to E, there exist u,v∈Vu, v \in V with θ(u)θ(v)≠θ(v)θ(u)\theta(u)\theta(v) \neq \theta(v)\theta(u). Fix an integer r≥1r \ge 1.

  1. There exist an integer n≥0n \ge 0 and selfadjoint elements x1,…,xr∈D⊗max(n+1)x_1, \dots, x_r \in D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+1)} such that, for every nonzero complex Hilbert space HH, every unital complex C*C^*-algebra BB, and all unital **-homomorphisms φ:D⊗max(n+1)→B(H)\varphi \colon D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+1)} \to B(H) and ψ:B→B(H)\psi \colon B \to B(H) satisfying φ(a)ψ(b)=ψ(b)φ(a)\varphi(a)\psi(b) = \psi(b)\varphi(a) for all a∈D⊗max(n+1)a \in D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+1)} and b∈Bb \in B and such that every T∈B(H)T \in B(H) commuting with φ(D⊗max(n+1))\varphi(D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+1)}) and ψ(B)\psi(B) is a complex scalar multiple of the identity operator on HH, φ(x1),…,φ(xr) are ℂ-linearly independent in B(H).\varphi(x_1), \dots, \varphi(x_r) \text{ are $\mathbb{C}$-linearly independent in } B(H).(3)✦

  2. There exist an integer n≥1n \ge 1 and elements y1,…,yr∈V⊗ℝny_1, \dots, y_r \in V^{\otimes_{\mathbb{R}} n} such that, for every nonzero complex Hilbert space HH, all factor von Neumann algebras M1,…,MnM_1, \dots, M_n on HH with Mj⊆Mi′M_j \subseteq M_i' for all distinct i,j∈{1,…,n}i, j \in \{1, \dots, n\}, and all unital **-homomorphisms φ1,…,φn:D→B(H)\varphi_1, \dots, \varphi_n \colon D \to B(H) with φi(D)⊆Mi\varphi_i(D) \subseteq M_i for each 1≤i≤n1 \le i \le n, writing f=(φ1|V,…,φn|V)f = (\varphi_1|_V, \dots, \varphi_n|_V) for the family of ℝ\mathbb{R}-linear restrictions to VV, mf(y1),…,mf(yr) are ℂ-linearly independent in B(H).m_f(y_1), \dots, m_f(y_r) \text{ are $\mathbb{C}$-linearly independent in } B(H).(4)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for DD and VV as in Lemma 4.3 and each r≥1r \ge 1, there exist n≥1n \ge 1 and selfadjoint elements x1,…,xr∈D⊗maxnx_1, \dots, x_r \in D^{\otimes_{\max} n} occupying the first nn legs whose images are ℂ\mathbb{C}-linearly independent in every irreducible representation of D⊗maxn⊗maxBD^{\otimes_{\max} n} \otimes_{\max} B for every nonzero unital C*C^*-algebra BB. Instead, the theorem above takes VV explicitly, uses the (n+1)(n+1)-fold power D⊗max(n+1)D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+1)} (n≥0n \ge 0) in (3) alongside the factor formulation (4), and replaces irreducible representations of D⊗maxn⊗maxBD^{\otimes_{\max} n} \otimes_{\max} B for nonzero BB by commuting unital **-homomorphisms of D⊗max(n+1)D^{\otimes_{\max}(n+1)} and a unital complex C*C^*-algebra BB on a nonzero complex Hilbert space with scalar joint commutant, without requiring BB to be nonzero.

What Is Checked

The claims (3) and (4) are stated over a unital complex C*C^*-algebra DD, a finite-dimensional real subspace VV of selfadjoint elements of DD with at least two elements having noncommuting images under every unital **-homomorphism from DD into a nonzero unital complex C*C^*-algebra, an integer r≥1r \ge 1, and, for a nonzero complex Hilbert space HH, both the maximal tensor powers (1) under commuting unital **-homomorphisms with a unital complex C*C^*-algebra BB into B(H)B(H) having scalar joint commutant and the tensor multiplication map (2) on real tensor powers of VV for unital **-homomorphisms from DD with ranges in pairwise commuting factor von Neumann algebras on HH.