OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 Β· Β§1. Introduction

Β§1 (setting) Ultrapower, central-sequence algebra, characters, Jiang-Su algebra, and I(2,3): For unital complex C*C^*-algebras, with diagonal embeddings, prime dimension-drop algebras, the algebra I(2,3)I(2,3), and the Jiang-Su algebra 𝒡\mathcal{Z}

Ultrapowers, central sequences, characterlessness, and minimal tensor products.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Take unital complex C*C^*-algebras AA and BB and an ultrafilter Ο‰\omega on β„•\mathbb{N}.

Supporting Constructions

For a unital complex C*C^*-algebra AA, the algebra of bounded sequences β„“βˆž(β„•,A)\ell^\infty(\mathbb{N}, A) is the unital C*C^*-algebra of norm-bounded sequences (an)nβˆˆβ„•(a_n)_{n \in \mathbb{N}} in AA✦, and the constant-sequence embedding c:Aβ†’β„“βˆž(β„•,A)c \colon A \to \ell^\infty(\mathbb{N}, A) is the unital **-homomorphism sending a∈Aa \in A to (a)nβˆˆβ„•(a)_{n \in \mathbb{N}}.✦ Given an ultrafilter Ο‰\omega on β„•\mathbb{N}, the norm ultralimit of x=(xn)nβˆˆβ„•βˆˆβ„“βˆž(β„•,A)x = (x_n)_{n \in \mathbb{N}} \in \ell^\infty(\mathbb{N}, A) along Ο‰\omega is the real number lim⁡nβ†’Ο‰βˆ₯xnβˆ₯\lim_{n \to \omega} \|x_n\|.✦ The null ideal IΟ‰I_\omega of β„“βˆž(β„•,A)\ell^\infty(\mathbb{N}, A) along Ο‰\omega is the two-sided idealΒ (1): IΟ‰={(xn)nβˆˆβ„•βˆˆβ„“βˆž(β„•,A):limnβ†’Ο‰βˆ₯xnβˆ₯=0}.I_\omega = \bigl\{ (x_n)_{n \in \mathbb{N}} \in \ell^\infty(\mathbb{N}, A) : \lim_{n \to \omega} \|x_n\| = 0 \bigr\}.(1)✦

A character on a unital complex C*C^*-algebra AA is a unital **-homomorphism A→ℂA \to \mathbb{C}.

For a finite set II, the matrix algebra MI(β„‚)M_I(\mathbb{C}) is the unital C*C^*-algebra of complex matrices with rows and columns indexed by II. For natural numbers n,p,qβˆˆβ„•n, p, q \in \mathbb{N}, let Mn(β„‚)M_n(\mathbb{C}) denote the matrix algebra indexed by {0,…,nβˆ’1}\{0, \dots, n - 1\}, write MpΓ—q(β„‚)M_{p \times q}(\mathbb{C}) for the matrix algebra indexed by {0,…,pβˆ’1}Γ—{0,…,qβˆ’1}\{0, \dots, p - 1\} \times \{0, \dots, q - 1\}✦, and set M6(β„‚)=M2Γ—3(β„‚)M_6(\mathbb{C}) = M_{2 \times 3}(\mathbb{C}).✦ For finite sets II and JJ, the left and right Kronecker embeddings Ξ»I,J:MI(β„‚)β†’MIΓ—J(β„‚)\lambda_{I,J} \colon M_I(\mathbb{C}) \to M_{I \times J}(\mathbb{C}) and ρI,J:MJ(β„‚)β†’MIΓ—J(β„‚)\rho_{I,J} \colon M_J(\mathbb{C}) \to M_{I \times J}(\mathbb{C}) are the unital **-homomorphisms Ξ»I,J(a)=aβŠ—1J\lambda_{I,J}(a) = a \otimes 1_J and ρI,J(b)=1IβŠ—b\rho_{I,J}(b) = 1_I \otimes b, where 1I1_I and 1J1_J are the identity matrices; denote their images by MI(β„‚)βŠ—1JM_I(\mathbb{C}) \otimes 1_J and 1IβŠ—MJ(β„‚)1_I \otimes M_J(\mathbb{C}), and write Mp(β„‚)βŠ—1qM_p(\mathbb{C}) \otimes 1_q and 1pβŠ—Mq(β„‚)1_p \otimes M_q(\mathbb{C}) on {0,…,pβˆ’1}Γ—{0,…,qβˆ’1}\{0, \dots, p - 1\} \times \{0, \dots, q - 1\}, as well as M2(β„‚)βŠ—13M_2(\mathbb{C}) \otimes 1_3 and 12βŠ—M3(β„‚)1_2 \otimes M_3(\mathbb{C}) in M6(β„‚)M_6(\mathbb{C}). Given finite sets II and JJ, the block-diagonal direct sum MI(β„‚)Γ—MJ(β„‚)β†’MIβŠ”J(β„‚)M_I(\mathbb{C}) \times M_J(\mathbb{C}) \to M_{I \sqcup J}(\mathbb{C}) is the unital **-homomorphism sending (a,b)(a,b) to diag⁡(a,b)\operatorname{diag}(a,b).✦ For a finite set II, the path algebra C([0,1],MI(β„‚))C([0,1], M_I(\mathbb{C})) is the unital C*C^*-algebra of continuous paths [0,1]β†’MI(β„‚)[0,1] \to M_I(\mathbb{C}); for each t∈[0,1]t \in [0,1], the evaluation map ev⁡t:C([0,1],MI(β„‚))β†’MI(β„‚)\operatorname{ev}_t \colon C([0,1], M_I(\mathbb{C})) \to M_I(\mathbb{C}) is the unital **-homomorphism ev⁡t(f)=f(t)\operatorname{ev}_t(f) = f(t).

An inductive system of unital complex C*C^*-algebras (An,Ο•i,j)(A_n, \phi_{i,j}) consists of unital complex C*C^*-algebras AnA_n (nβˆˆβ„•n \in \mathbb{N}) and isometric unital **-homomorphisms Ο•i,j:Aiβ†’Aj\phi_{i,j} \colon A_i \to A_j (i≀ji \le j) satisfying Ο•i,i=idAi\phi_{i,i} = \mathrm{id}_{A_i} and Ο•j,kβˆ˜Ο•i,j=Ο•i,k\phi_{j,k} \circ \phi_{i,j} = \phi_{i,k} for i≀j≀ki \le j \le k.✦ An inductive chain (An,Οƒn)(A_n, \sigma_n) consists of unital complex C*C^*-algebras AnA_n (nβˆˆβ„•n \in \mathbb{N}) and one-step isometric unital **-homomorphisms Οƒn:Anβ†’An+1\sigma_n \colon A_n \to A_{n+1}, whose compositions yield an inductive system.✦ The inductive limit limβ†’(An,Ο•i,j)\underset{\longrightarrow}{\lim} (A_n, \phi_{i,j}) of an inductive system (An,Ο•i,j)(A_n, \phi_{i,j}) of unital complex C*C^*-algebras is the completion of its algebraic direct limit.

When KK and II are finite sets, the block-diagonal embedding is the unital **-homomorphism mapping an II-tuple (ai)i∈I(a_i)_{i \in I} in MK(β„‚)M_K(\mathbb{C}) to the block-diagonal matrix diag⁡(ai)i∈I∈MKΓ—I(β„‚)\operatorname{diag}(a_i)_{i \in I} \in M_{K \times I}(\mathbb{C}).✦ For a family of continuous paths ΞΎi:[0,1]β†’[0,1]\xi_i \colon [0,1] \to [0,1] (i∈Ii \in I) and t∈[0,1]t \in [0,1], block evaluation at tt is the unital **-homomorphism C([0,1],MK(β„‚))β†’MKΓ—I(β„‚)C([0,1], M_K(\mathbb{C})) \to M_{K \times I}(\mathbb{C}) sending ff to diag⁡(f(ΞΎi(t)))i∈I\operatorname{diag}(f(\xi_i(t)))_{i \in I}✦, and varying t∈[0,1]t \in [0,1] gives the block-diagonal path homomorphism C([0,1],MK(β„‚))β†’C([0,1],MKΓ—I(β„‚))C([0,1], M_K(\mathbb{C})) \to C([0,1], M_{K \times I}(\mathbb{C})).✦ Every permutation Οƒ\sigma of a finite set LL defines a unitary permutation matrix UΟƒβˆˆML(β„‚)U_\sigma \in M_L(\mathbb{C})✦, and for any two permutations Οƒ\sigma and Ο„\tau of LL the permutation unitaries UΟƒU_\sigma and UΟ„U_\tau are joined by a continuous path of unitaries in ML(β„‚)M_L(\mathbb{C}).✦ Given two bijections e0,e1:KΓ—Iβ†’Le_0, e_1 \colon K \times I \to L and t∈[0,1]t \in [0,1], unitary path interpolation composes reindexing along e0e_0 with conjugation by the unitary path joining 1L1_L to Ue1∘e0βˆ’1U_{e_1 \circ e_0^{-1}} at tt, producing a unital **-isomorphism MKΓ—I(β„‚)β†’βˆΌML(β„‚)M_{K \times I}(\mathbb{C}) \xrightarrow{\sim} M_L(\mathbb{C}).✦

On [0,1][0,1], the midpoint is 1/21/2✦, and the lower and upper eigenvalue paths Ξ»βˆ’,Ξ»+:[0,1]β†’[0,1]\lambda_-, \lambda_+ \colon [0,1] \to [0,1] are the continuous paths Ξ»βˆ’(t)=t/2\lambda_-(t) = t/2 and Ξ»+(t)=(t+1)/2\lambda_+(t) = (t+1)/2. For natural numbers p,q,P,Qβˆˆβ„•p, q, P, Q \in \mathbb{N}, a connecting datum from (p,q)(p,q) to (P,Q)(P,Q) consists of natural numbers kβˆ’>0k_- > 0, k+>0k_+ > 0, k0k_0, z0z_0, z1z_1, w0w_0, and w1w_1 satisfyingΒ (2): qkβˆ’=z0Q,k++k0=z1Q,pz0+pqz1=P,pk+=Pw0,kβˆ’+k0=Pw1,qw0+pqw1=Q.\begin{aligned} q k_- &= z_0 Q, & k_+ + k_0 &= z_1 Q, & p z_0 + p q z_1 &= P, \\ p k_+ &= P w_0, & k_- + k_0 &= P w_1, & q w_0 + p q w_1 &= Q. \end{aligned}(2)✦ Given a connecting datum from (p,q)(p,q) to (P,Q)(P,Q), the eigenvalue-path assignment sends kβˆ’k_- slots to Ξ»βˆ’\lambda_-, k+k_+ slots to Ξ»+\lambda_+, and k0k_0 slots to the constant path 1/21/2.✦ Composing block evaluation at t∈[0,1]t \in [0,1] with unitary path interpolation between endpoint index bijections matchingΒ (2) yields the interpolated fiber map at tt✦, and assembling these maps over t∈[0,1]t \in [0,1] gives the interpolated path homomorphism C([0,1],MpΓ—q(β„‚))β†’C([0,1],MPΓ—Q(β„‚))C([0,1], M_{p \times q}(\mathbb{C})) \to C([0,1], M_{P \times Q}(\mathbb{C})).✦

In the standard multiplicity scheme, the stage dimensions satisfy p0=2p_0 = 2 and pn+1=pn7p_{n+1} = p_n^7 (nβˆˆβ„•n \in \mathbb{N})✦, and for each pβ‰₯2p \ge 2 the factor k(p)=(pβˆ’1)(p4+p2+1)k(p) = (p-1)(p^4 + p^2 + 1) gives connecting multiplicitiesΒ (3) for a datum from (p,p+1)(p, p+1) to (p7,p7+1)(p^7, p^7+1): kβˆ’(p)=pk(p)+1,k+(p)=(p+1)k(p)+1,k0(p)=p(p+1)k(p)2βˆ’1.k_-(p) = p\,k(p) + 1, \qquad k_+(p) = (p+1)\,k(p) + 1, \qquad k_0(p) = p(p+1)\,k(p)^2 - 1.(3)

The algebraic tensor product AβŠ—β„‚BA \otimes_{\mathbb{C}} B of two unital complex C*C^*-algebras AA and BB is their tensor product as complex **-algebras.✦

The Claim

Definition 1. For a unital complex C*C^*-algebra AA and an ultrafilter Ο‰\omega on β„•\mathbb{N}, the norm ultrapower AΟ‰A_\omega of AA along Ο‰\omega is the quotient C*C^*-algebraΒ (4): AΟ‰=β„“βˆž(β„•,A)/IΟ‰.A_\omega = \ell^\infty(\mathbb{N}, A) / I_\omega.(4)✦ For a unital complex C*C^*-algebra AA and an ultrafilter Ο‰\omega on β„•\mathbb{N}, with canonical quotient **-homomorphism πω:β„“βˆž(β„•,A)β†’AΟ‰\pi_\omega \colon \ell^\infty(\mathbb{N}, A) \to A_\omega, the ultrapower diagonal embedding ΞΉΟ‰:Aβ†’AΟ‰\iota_\omega \colon A \to A_\omega is the unital **-homomorphismΒ (5): ΞΉΟ‰=Ο€Ο‰βˆ˜c.\iota_\omega = \pi_\omega \circ c.(5)✦ For a unital complex C*C^*-algebra AA and an ultrafilter Ο‰\omega on β„•\mathbb{N}, the centralizer **-subalgebra π’žΟ‰(A)\mathcal{C}_\omega(A) of ΞΉΟ‰(A)\iota_\omega(A) in AΟ‰A_\omega is defined byΒ (6), where Sβ€²S' denotes the commutant of SβŠ†AΟ‰S \subseteq A_\omega: π’žΟ‰(A)=AΟ‰βˆ©ΞΉΟ‰(A)β€²={x∈AΟ‰:xΞΉΟ‰(a)=ΞΉΟ‰(a)x for all a∈A}.\mathcal{C}_\omega(A) = A_\omega \cap \iota_\omega(A)' = \bigl\{ x \in A_\omega : x\,\iota_\omega(a) = \iota_\omega(a)\,x \text{ for all } a \in A \bigr\}.(6)✦ The central-sequence algebra FΟ‰(A)F_\omega(A) is defined byΒ (7): FΟ‰(A)=π’žΟ‰(A).F_\omega(A) = \mathcal{C}_\omega(A).(7)✦ A unital complex C*C^*-algebra AA has no characters if every non-unital **-homomorphism Aβ†’β„‚A \to \mathbb{C} vanishes identically✦; for any unital complex C*C^*-algebra AA, having no characters is characterized byΒ (8): A has no characters⇔there is no unital *-homomorphism Aβ†’β„‚.A \text{ has no characters} \iff \text{there is no unital } *\text{-homomorphism } A \to \mathbb{C}.(8)✦ For natural numbers p,qβˆˆβ„•p, q \in \mathbb{N}, the prime dimension-drop algebra I(p,q)I(p,q) is the unital **-subalgebra of C([0,1],MpΓ—q(β„‚))C([0,1], M_{p \times q}(\mathbb{C})) defined byΒ (9): I(p,q)={f∈C([0,1],MpΓ—q(β„‚)):f(0)∈Mp(β„‚)βŠ—1q,f(1)∈1pβŠ—Mq(β„‚)}.I(p,q) = \bigl\{ f \in C\bigl([0,1], M_{p \times q}(\mathbb{C})\bigr) : f(0) \in M_p(\mathbb{C}) \otimes 1_q,\; f(1) \in 1_p \otimes M_q(\mathbb{C}) \bigr\}.(9)✦ The dimension-drop algebra I(2,3)I(2,3) is the unital **-subalgebra of C([0,1],M6(β„‚))C([0,1], M_6(\mathbb{C})) defined byΒ (10): I(2,3)={f∈C([0,1],M6(β„‚)):f(0)∈M2(β„‚)βŠ—13,f(1)∈12βŠ—M3(β„‚)}.I(2,3) = \bigl\{ f \in C\bigl([0,1], M_6(\mathbb{C})\bigr) : f(0) \in M_2(\mathbb{C}) \otimes 1_3,\; f(1) \in 1_2 \otimes M_3(\mathbb{C}) \bigr\}.(10)✦ Restricting the interpolated path homomorphism for a connecting datum from (p,q)(p,q) to (P,Q)(P,Q) yields a connecting unital **-homomorphism I(p,q)β†’I(P,Q)I(p,q) \to I(P,Q).✦ A prime-drop presentation consists of sequences pn=2en+1p_n = 2^{e_n + 1} (enβˆˆβ„•e_n \in \mathbb{N}) and connecting data from (pn,pn+1)(p_n, p_n+1) to (pn+1,pn+1+1)(p_{n+1}, p_{n+1}+1) with endpoint parameters z0(n),z1(n),w0(n),w1(n)z_0(n), z_1(n), w_0(n), w_1(n) satisfying z0(n)+(pn+1)z1(n)β‰₯2z_0(n) + (p_n+1)z_1(n) \ge 2 and w0(n)+pnw1(n)β‰₯2w_0(n) + p_n w_1(n) \ge 2, generating an inductive chain and system (I(pn,pn+1),Ο•i,j)(I(p_n, p_n+1), \phi_{i,j}).✦ For the standard prime-drop presentation given byΒ (3) starting at p0=2p_0 = 2, the Jiang-Su algebra 𝒡\mathcal{Z} is the unital C*C^*-algebra inductive limitΒ (11): 𝒡=limβ†’(I(pn,pn+1),Ο•i,j).\mathcal{Z} = \underset{\longrightarrow}{\lim} \bigl(I(p_n, p_n+1),\, \phi_{i,j}\bigr).(11)✦ For unital complex C*C^*-algebras AA and BB, let βˆ₯β‹…βˆ₯min\|\cdot\|_{\min} denote the supremum of spatial cross-seminorms on AβŠ—β„‚BA \otimes_{\mathbb{C}} B; the minimal tensor product AβŠ—minBA \otimes_{\min} B of AA and BB is the C*C^*-algebra completion of AβŠ—β„‚BA \otimes_{\mathbb{C}} B with respect to βˆ₯β‹…βˆ₯min\|\cdot\|_{\min}Β (12): AβŠ—minB=AβŠ—β„‚BΒ―βˆ₯β‹…βˆ₯min.A \otimes_{\min} B = \overline{A \otimes_{\mathbb{C}} B}^{\,\|\cdot\|_{\min}}.(12)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a nonzero unital separable complex C*C^*-algebra AA and a free ultrafilter Ο‰\omega on β„•\mathbb{N}, AΟ‰=β„“βˆž(β„•,A)/{(an):lim⁡nβ†’Ο‰βˆ₯anβˆ₯=0}A_\omega = \ell^\infty(\mathbb{N}, A) / \{(a_n) : \lim_{n \to \omega} \|a_n\| = 0\}, FΟ‰(A)=AΟ‰βˆ©Aβ€²F_\omega(A) = A_\omega \cap A', a character is a nonzero **-homomorphism to β„‚\mathbb{C}, 𝒡\mathcal{Z} is the Jiang-Su algebra, and I(2,3)={f∈C([0,1],M2(β„‚)βŠ—M3(β„‚)):f(0)∈M2(β„‚)βŠ—13,f(1)∈12βŠ—M3(β„‚)}I(2,3) = \{f \in C([0,1], M_2(\mathbb{C}) \otimes M_3(\mathbb{C})) : f(0) \in M_2(\mathbb{C}) \otimes 1_3,\, f(1) \in 1_2 \otimes M_3(\mathbb{C})\}.

What Is Checked

The definitions and characterlessness equivalence are stated over arbitrary unital complex C*C^*-algebras AA and BB, an arbitrary ultrafilter Ο‰\omega on β„•\mathbb{N}, arbitrary natural numbers p,qβˆˆβ„•p, q \in \mathbb{N} together with (2,3)(2,3), and the standard prime-drop presentation starting at p0=2p_0 = 2. For every pβ‰₯2p \ge 2, the standard multiplicities satisfy the connecting identitiesΒ (2), positivity conditions, power-of-two size relation, and endpoint copy bounds, and the resulting connecting steps preserve the prime dimension-drop subalgebras as isometric maps forming an inductive system.