The Setting
Let be a nonempty dense linear order without endpoints, an infinite cardinal and a set of at most points of . The question is a downward Löwenheim-Skolem one with an extra demand: should lie in a suborder of of size at most that is again dense without endpoints and is moreover convex in . Lemma 3.11 concerns orders in which every closed interval is countable.
Intervals and Convex Sets
For , the closed interval of is the set of points of between and : (1) The order has countable closed intervals when is countable for all . The rationals have countable closed intervals, and so does the product ordered lexicographically, an order of size ; the real line does not, since there a closed interval between two distinct points has the size of the continuum.
A convex subset of is a subset of that contains the closed interval between any two of its points: (2)
A subset of is dense without endpoints when, in the order of , between any two points of lies a third point of , and no point of is least or greatest in .
The Claim
Theorem 1. Let be a nonempty dense linear order without endpoints whose closed intervals are countable, let be an infinite cardinal, and let be a subset of with . Then there is a nonempty convex subset of that is dense without endpoints and satisfies (3)✦
What Is Checked
The claim (3) is stated over a nonempty dense linear order without endpoints whose closed intervals (1) are countable, an infinite cardinal and a subset of with , with convexity as in (2).