OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §1. Introduction

AECs, categoricity, the Hanf function and the two cardinals: 2ℵ0=ℵ12^{\aleph_0}=\aleph_1, h(κ)=ℶ(2κ)+h(\kappa)=\beth_{(2^\kappa)^+}, the endpoint ℶω2\beth_{\omega_2}, the tail threshold h(ℵ1)h(\aleph_1), and two nonisomorphic models in a cardinal μ\mu

The continuum hypothesis, the Hanf function and categoricity.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let KK be an abstract elementary class with Löwenheim-Skolem number LS(K)\mathrm{LS}(K). Shelah’s eventual categoricity conjecture says that if KK is categorical in some cardinal not below a threshold that depends only on LS(K)\mathrm{LS}(K), then it is categorical in every cardinal not below that threshold; in its strong form the threshold is the Hanf number of KK. Under the continuum hypothesis (CH), a class with LS(K)=ℵ0\mathrm{LS}(K)=\aleph_0 has Hanf number ℶω2\beth_{\omega_2}.

The library defines the hypothesis CH, the Hanf function hh built from the beth function ℶ\beth, the two beth cardinals, the endpoint ℶω2\beth_{\omega_2} and the tail threshold Λ=h(ℵ1)\Lambda=h(\aleph_1), and two properties a class of structures may have at a cardinal μ\mu: to be categorical in μ\mu, and to have two nonisomorphic models of cardinality μ\mu.

Structures and Classes

A relational language LL is a family of sets LnL_n, n∈ℕn\in\mathbb{N}, whose members are the nn-ary relation symbols of LL. An LL-structure MM is a set |M||M| in the von Neumann hierarchy, its carrier, together with an nn-ary relation rM⊆|M|nr^M\subseteq|M|^n for each nn-ary symbol rr of LL; its cardinality ∥M∥\|M\| is that of |M||M|.✦

An isomorphism f:M→Nf\colon M\to N of LL-structures is a bijection from |M||M| onto |N||N| such that, for every nn-ary symbol rr of LL and all a0,…,an−1∈|M|a_0,\dots,a_{n-1}\in|M|, rM(a0,…,an−1)⇔rN(f(a0),…,f(an−1)).r^M(a_0,\dots,a_{n-1}) \iff r^N\bigl(f(a_0),\dots,f(a_{n-1})\bigr).(1)✦ Two LL-structures MM and NN are isomorphic, M≅NM\cong N, when there is an isomorphism from MM to NN.

A class KK of LL-structures is a collection of LL-structures, the models of KK, together with a binary relation ≤K\le_K on LL-structures, the strong substructure relation of KK.✦

The Definition

Definition 1. The continuum hypothesis CH is the statement that, in the fixed universe of sets, 2ℵ0=ℵ1.2^{\aleph_0}=\aleph_1.(2)✦ The Hanf function assigns to each cardinal κ\kappa the cardinal h(κ)=ℶ(2κ)+,h(\kappa)=\beth_{(2^\kappa)^+},(3)✦ the index (2κ)+(2^\kappa)^+ being the initial ordinal of the successor cardinal of 2κ2^\kappa. The endpoint is the cardinal ℶω2,\beth_{\omega_2},(4)✦ and the tail threshold is the cardinal Λ=ℶξ+=h(ℵ1),ξ=2ℵ1.\Lambda=\beth_{\xi^+}=h(\aleph_1),\qquad \xi=2^{\aleph_1}.(5)✦ Let KK be a class of LL-structures and μ\mu a cardinal, and let KμK_\mu be the collection of models of KK of cardinality μ\mu. The class KK is categorical in μ\mu when it has a model of cardinality μ\mu and any two of its models of cardinality μ\mu are isomorphic: Kμ≠∅andM≅N for all M,N∈Kμ.K_\mu\neq\emptyset \quad\text{and}\quad M\cong N \text{ for all } M,N\in K_\mu.(6)✦ The class KK has two nonisomorphic models in μ\mu when some two of its models of cardinality μ\mu are not isomorphic: M≆N for some M,N∈Kμ.M\not\cong N \text{ for some } M,N\in K_\mu.(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: CH is assumed, h(κ)=ℶ(2κ)+h(\kappa)=\beth_{(2^\kappa)^+}, the Hanf number of KK is H(K)=h(LS(K))H(K)=h(\mathrm{LS}(K)), categoricity of KK in κ\kappa means that KK has exactly one model of cardinality κ\kappa up to isomorphism, existence included, and Λ=ℶ(2ℵ1)+\Lambda=\beth_{(2^{\aleph_1})^+}.

What Is Checked

CH, the Hanf function, the endpoint and the tail threshold are stated in terms of cardinal exponentiation, successor cardinals and the beth function. The two properties of a class are stated over LL-structures whose carriers lie in the von Neumann hierarchy, with their isomorphisms, and over classes of LL-structures with a strong substructure relation.