OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Kummer duality and the group input

Kummer theory identifies Π_F^a with W_F: Compatible primitive roots of unity give ℤℓ≅Tℓ(F)\mathbb{Z}_\ell\cong T_\ell(F), and in characteristic other than ℓ\ell the pairing detects ℓe\ell^eth powers in F×F^\times

Kummer characters pair F×F^\times with ΠFa\Pi_F^a..

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let ℓ\ell be a prime, kk an algebraically closed field and FF a field containing kk, such as a function field K/kK/k. Write F‾\bar F for an algebraic closure of FF and μn(F‾)\mu_n(\bar F) for its group of nnth roots of unity. Kummer theory relates the multiplicative group F×F^\times to the Galois group of FF: an automorphism σ\sigma of F‾\bar F over FF moves an ℓe\ell^eth root α\alpha of f∈F×f\in F^\times to ζα\zeta\alpha with ζ∈μℓe(F‾)\zeta\in\mu_{\ell^e}(\bar F). The question is which elements of F×F^\times these roots of unity tell apart, and through which quotient of the Galois group they factor.

When ℓ\ell is not the characteristic of FF, taking all levels ee together replaces μℓe(F‾)\mu_{\ell^e}(\bar F) by the Tate module of ℓ\ell-power roots of unity, a free ℤℓ\mathbb{Z}_\ell-module of rank one without a preferred generator.

Galois Groups and Power Classes

For a field FF, the absolute Galois group GFG_F is the profinite group of automorphisms of F‾\bar F over FF. For a topological group GG, the pro-ℓ\ell kernel Nℓ(G)N_\ell(G) is the intersection of the open normal subgroups HH of GG such that G/HG/H is an ℓ\ell-group.✦ The maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotient of GFG_F is GF(ℓ)=GF/Nℓ(GF),G_F^{(\ell)}=G_F/N_\ell(G_F),(1)✦ and the abelianization ΠFa\Pi_F^a of GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)} is its quotient by the closure of its commutator subgroup: ΠFa=GF(ℓ)/[GF(ℓ),GF(ℓ)]¯.\Pi_F^a=G_F^{(\ell)}\big/\,\overline{[G_F^{(\ell)},G_F^{(\ell)}]}.(2)✦

For a commutative group GG and a natural number qq, the subgroup of qqth powers of GG is Gq={xq:x∈G}G^q=\{x^q:x\in G\}✦, and the group of qqth power classes is the quotient group G/GqG/G^q, whose elements are the cosets xGqxG^q.✦ For a field FF and e≥0e\ge0, the group of ℓe\ell^eth power classes of F×F^\times is the group of qqth power classes of G=F×G=F^\times for q=ℓeq=\ell^e, and is written F×/F×ℓeF^\times/F^{\times\ell^e}.

The Claim

Definition 1. Let FF be a field. The Tate module Tℓ(F)T_\ell(F) is the inverse limit of the groups μℓe(F‾)\mu_{\ell^e}(\bar F) along the transition maps μℓe+1(F‾)→μℓe(F‾)\mu_{\ell^{e+1}}(\bar F)\to \mu_{\ell^e}(\bar F), ζ↦ζℓ\zeta\mapsto\zeta^\ell: Tℓ(F)={(ζe)e≥0∈∏e≥0μℓe(F‾):ζe+1ℓ=ζefor every e≥0}.T_\ell(F)=\Bigl\{(\zeta_e)_{e\ge0}\in\prod_{e\ge0}\mu_{\ell^e}(\bar F)\;:\; \zeta_{e+1}^{\ell}=\zeta_e\ \text{for every } e\ge0\Bigr\}.(3)✦ Let AA be an algebraically closed field of characteristic different from ℓ\ell. Then AA has a compatible system of primitive roots of unity: a sequence (ζe)e≥0(\zeta_e)_{e\ge0} in A×A^\times with ζea primitive ℓeth root of unity andζe+1ℓ=ζefor every e≥0.\zeta_e\ \text{a primitive $\ell^e$th root of unity and}\ \zeta_{e+1}^{\ell}=\zeta_e \quad\text{for every } e\ge0.(4)✦ For such a system in F‾\bar F, the isomorphisms ℤ/ℓe→μℓe(F‾)\mathbb{Z}/\ell^e\to\mu_{\ell^e}(\bar F), m↦ζemm\mapsto\zeta_e^m, combine into the isomorphism of topological groups ℤℓ→∼Tℓ(F),a↦(ζeamod⁡ℓe)e≥0.\mathbb{Z}_\ell\xrightarrow{\ \sim\ }T_\ell(F),\qquad a\longmapsto\bigl(\zeta_e^{\,a\bmod\ell^e}\bigr)_{e\ge0}.(5)✦

Suppose now that FF contains an algebraically closed field kk. For n≥1n\ge1 and f∈F×f\in F^\times, fix an nnth root αf\alpha_f of ff in F‾\bar F.✦ The Kummer character of ff at level nn is the homomorphism sending σ\sigma to the Kummer ratio σ(αf)/αf\sigma(\alpha_f)/\alpha_f: κf(n):GF→μn(F‾),σ↦σ(αf)/αf.\kappa_f^{(n)}\colon G_F\longrightarrow\mu_n(\bar F),\qquad \sigma\longmapsto\sigma(\alpha_f)/\alpha_f.(6)✦ Fix e≥0e\ge0. The character κf(ℓe)\kappa_f^{(\ell^e)} induces a character of GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)}✦ and then a character κf:ΠFa→μℓe(F‾)\kappa_f\colon\Pi_F^a\to\mu_{\ell^e}(\bar F)✦, and the Kummer pairing (f,σ)↦κf(σ)(f,\sigma)\mapsto\kappa_f(\sigma) of F×F^\times with ΠFa\Pi_F^a is the homomorphism F×→Hom⁡(ΠFa,μℓe(F‾)),f↦κf.F^\times\longrightarrow\operatorname{Hom}\bigl(\Pi_F^a,\mu_{\ell^e}(\bar F)\bigr),\qquad f\longmapsto\kappa_f.(7)✦ If moreover FF has characteristic different from ℓ\ell, then for every f∈F×f\in F^\times κf=1⇔f=gℓefor some g∈F×,\kappa_f=1\iff f=g^{\ell^e}\ \text{for some } g\in F^\times,(8)✦ and any f,g∈F×f,g\in F^\times with κf(σ)=κg(σ)\kappa_f(\sigma)=\kappa_g(\sigma) for every σ∈ΠFa\sigma\in\Pi_F^a satisfy fF×ℓe=gF×ℓein F×/F×ℓe.fF^{\times\ell^e}=gF^{\times\ell^e}\quad\text{in } F^\times/F^{\times\ell^e}.(9)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for a field FF of characteristic different from ℓ\ell, a compatible system of ℓ\ell-power roots of unity identifies ℤℓ(1)\mathbb{Z}_\ell(1) with ℤℓ\mathbb{Z}_\ell, and Kummer theory identifies ΠFa\Pi_F^a with WF=Hom⁡(F×,ℤℓ)W_F=\operatorname{Hom}(F^\times,\mathbb{Z}_\ell), where ℤℓ(1)\mathbb{Z}_\ell(1) stands for the Tate module Tℓ(F)T_\ell(F). The library states the Kummer side at each finite level ℓe\ell^e, through the pairing (7).

What Is Checked

The claims are stated over the Tate module Tℓ(F)T_\ell(F) of a field FF and the additive group ℤℓ\mathbb{Z}_\ell, and, for FF containing an algebraically closed field kk, over the quotient GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)} of GFG_F by its pro-ℓ\ell kernel, the quotient ΠFa\Pi_F^a of GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)} by its closed commutator subgroup and the group F×/F×ℓeF^\times/F^{\times\ell^e} of power classes, with FF of characteristic different from ℓ\ell in (8) and (9).

About these constructions the library proves that the Kummer character κf(ℓe)\kappa_f^{(\ell^e)} is trivial on Nℓ(GF)N_\ell(G_F)✦, and that the character of GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)} it induces is trivial on the closure of the commutator subgroup of GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)}.✦