OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Kummer duality and the group input

Lemma 2.2: EE relatively algebraically closed in FF, image ℓ\ell-saturated; F/EF/E finite over algebraically closed kk, norm after inclusion is the [F:E][F:E]th power

Injectivity of Eˆ→Fˆ\widehat E\to\widehat F for two kinds of subfield.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let ℓ\ell be a prime, kk an algebraically closed field of characteristic different from ℓ\ell, and FF a function field over kk, with ΠFa\Pi^a_F the quotient of the maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotient GF(ℓ)G^{(\ell)}_F of its absolute Galois group by its closed commutator subgroup. Kummer theory identifies F×/F×ℓeF^\times/F^{\times\ell^e} with the group of continuous homomorphisms ΠFa→μℓe\Pi^a_F\to\mu_{\ell^e}, so the completed multiplicative group Fˆ=lim←eF×/F×ℓe\widehat F=\underset{\longleftarrow}{\lim}_e F^\times/F^{\times\ell^e} is the Kummer dual of ΠFa\Pi^a_F. A subfield E⊇kE\supseteq k of FF gives the map Eˆ→Fˆ\widehat E\to\widehat F induced by E×⊆F×E^\times\subseteq F^\times, dual to the restriction ΠFa→ΠEa\Pi^a_F\to\Pi^a_E.

Classes can die along this map: for E=k(t)E=k(t) and F=k(t1/ℓ)F=k(t^{1/\ell}), the class of tt is nontrivial in E×/E×ℓE^\times/E^{\times\ell} and trivial in F×/F×ℓF^\times/F^{\times\ell}. The question is when no class dies, at a finite level or in the completions, and what the image of Eˆ\widehat E in Fˆ\widehat F looks like.

The library answers it for a subfield EE of FF that is relatively algebraically closed, meaning that every element of FF algebraic over EE lies in EE, and for a subfield EE over which FF is finite, where the norm NF/E:F×→E×N_{F/E}\colon F^\times\to E^\times gives a map Fˆ→Eˆ\widehat F\to\widehat E back.

Power Classes and Completions

For a commutative group GG, written multiplicatively, and a natural number qq, the subgroup of qqth powers GqG^q of GG is the image {xq:x∈G}\{x^q : x\in G\} of the homomorphism x↦xqx\mapsto x^q.✦ The group of power classes G/GqG/G^q is the quotient group of GG by GqG^q; for the unit group of a field these are F×qF^{\times q} and F×/F×qF^\times/F^{\times q}.✦

The map fqf_q induced by a homomorphism f:G→Hf\colon G\to H of commutative groups is the homomorphism G/Gq→H/HqG/G^q\to H/H^q given by fq(xGq)=f(x)Hqf_q(xG^q)=f(x)H^q.✦ For natural numbers qq and rr with q∣rq\mid r, the reduction ρr,q:G/Gr→G/Gq\rho_{r,q}\colon G/G^r\to G/G^q is the homomorphism xGr↦xGqxG^r\mapsto xG^q.✦

For a commutative group GG and a natural number ℓ\ell, the ℓ\ell-adic power completion Gˆ\widehat G of GG is the inverse limit of the groups G/GℓnG/G^{\ell^n} along the reductions, the subgroup of their product formed by the compatible families: Gˆ={(xn)n≥0∈∏n≥0G/Gℓn:ρℓn+1,ℓn(xn+1)=xnfor every n≥0}.\widehat G=\Bigl\{(x_n)_{n\ge0}\in\prod_{n\ge0}G/G^{\ell^n} : \rho_{\ell^{n+1},\ell^n}(x_{n+1})=x_n\ \text{for every } n\ge0\Bigr\}.(1) For a field FF, the completed multiplicative group Fˆ\widehat F of FF is the ℓ\ell-adic power completion of the group F×F^\times. The homomorphism fˆ:Gˆ→Hˆ\widehat f\colon\widehat G\to\widehat H induced by ff applies fℓnf_{\ell^n} to the nnth term: fˆ((xn)n≥0)=(fℓn(xn))n≥0\widehat f\bigl((x_n)_{n\ge0}\bigr)=\bigl(f_{\ell^n}(x_n)\bigr)_{n\ge0}.✦

Subfields and Their Unit Groups

A field EE is relatively algebraically closed in an extension field FF if every element of FF that is algebraic over EE lies in EE.✦

The inclusion ι:E×→F×\iota\colon E^\times\to F^\times of an extension F/EF/E of fields is the homomorphism of unit groups sending each nonzero element of EE to itself in FF.✦ The maps induced by ι\iota are ιq:E×/E×q→F×/F×q\iota_q\colon E^\times/E^{\times q}\to F^\times/F^{\times q} and ιˆ:Eˆ→Fˆ\widehat\iota\colon\widehat E\to\widehat F.

The norm NF/E:F×→E×N_{F/E}\colon F^\times\to E^\times of an extension F/EF/E sends each a∈F×a\in F^\times to the determinant of the EE-linear map x↦axx\mapsto ax of FF, and NˆF/E:Fˆ→Eˆ\widehat N_{F/E}\colon\widehat F\to\widehat E is the homomorphism induced by NF/EN_{F/E}. The degree [F:E][F:E] is the dimension of FF as a vector space over EE. When F/EF/E is infinite, the norm is taken to be 11 on every element and [F:E][F:E] to be 00, so that (7) says something only for finite F/EF/E.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let ℓ\ell be a natural number and F/EF/E an extension of fields.

  1. If EE is relatively algebraically closed in FF, then for every integer q≥1q\ge1 the map ιq:E×/E×q→F×/F×q\iota_q\colon E^\times/E^{\times q}\longrightarrow F^\times/F^{\times q}(2)✦ is injective.

  2. If f:G→Hf\colon G\to H is a homomorphism of commutative groups and fℓnf_{\ell^n} is injective for every n≥0n\ge0, then the map fˆ:Gˆ→Hˆ\widehat f\colon\widehat G\longrightarrow\widehat H(3)✦ is injective.

  3. If EE is relatively algebraically closed in FF and ℓ≥1\ell\ge1, then the image of ιˆ\widehat\iota is ℓ\ell-saturated in Fˆ\widehat F: for x∈Fˆx\in\widehat F, xℓ∈ιˆ(Eˆ)impliesx∈ιˆ(Eˆ).x^{\ell}\in\widehat\iota(\widehat E)\quad\text{implies}\quad x\in\widehat\iota(\widehat E).(4)✦

  4. If EE is relatively algebraically closed in FF and ℓ\ell is prime, then the image of ιˆ\widehat\iota is mm-saturated in Fˆ\widehat F for every integer m≥1m\ge1: for x∈Fˆx\in\widehat F, xm∈ιˆ(Eˆ)impliesx∈ιˆ(Eˆ).x^{m}\in\widehat\iota(\widehat E)\quad\text{implies}\quad x\in\widehat\iota(\widehat E).(5)✦

  5. If EE contains an algebraically closed field kk, F/EF/E is finite and ℓ\ell is prime, then the map ιˆ:Eˆ→Fˆ\widehat\iota\colon\widehat E\longrightarrow\widehat F(6)✦ is injective.

  6. For every x∈Eˆx\in\widehat E, NˆF/E(ιˆ(x))=x[F:E].\widehat N_{F/E}\bigl(\widehat\iota(x)\bigr)=x^{[F:E]}.(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for function fields E⊂FE\subset F over the same algebraically closed field kk, (1) if EE is relatively algebraically closed in FF, then Eˆ→Fˆ\widehat E\to\widehat F is injective with closed, ℓ\ell-saturated image, and restriction WF→WEW_F\to W_E is a continuous surjection, where WF=Hom⁡(F×,ℤℓ)W_F=\operatorname{Hom}(F^\times,\mathbb Z_\ell); (2) if F/EF/E is finite, then Eˆ→Fˆ\widehat E\to\widehat F is injective, and inclusion followed by norm is multiplication by [F:E][F:E].

The injectivity of ιˆ\widehat\iota for EE relatively algebraically closed in FF and ℓ≥1\ell\ge1 is (3) for f=ιf=\iota, whose hypothesis is (2) at the levels q=ℓnq=\ell^n.

What Is Checked

The claims are stated over the groups of power classes G/GqG/G^q with the induced maps fqf_q and the reductions ρr,q\rho_{r,q}, the power completion (1) with the induced maps fˆ\widehat f, the inclusion ι\iota and the norm NF/EN_{F/E} of unit groups, and relative algebraic closedness of a subfield.

Of these constructions the library proves that a homomorphism ff carries GqG^q into HqH^q, so that fqf_q is a homomorphism of the quotients, and that Gr⊆GqG^r\subseteq G^q for q∣rq\mid r, which gives the reduction ρr,q\rho_{r,q}. It also proves that the compatible families form a subgroup of ∏n≥0G/Gℓn\prod_{n\ge0}G/G^{\ell^n}, and that the maps fℓnf_{\ell^n} commute with the reductions, so that fˆ\widehat f sends compatible families to compatible families.