OctoInform Beta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §2. Kummer duality and the group input

Lemma 2.1: For a function field FF over an algebraically closed field kk, the class map F×→FˆF^\times \to \widehat F has kernel exactly k×k^\times

Completed multiplicative groups over algebraically closed fields are torsion-free.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Fix a prime ℓ\ell, an algebraically closed field kk and a field FF containing kk. Write ΠFa\Pi_F^a for the abelianization of the maximal pro-ℓ\ell quotient GF(ℓ)G_F^{(\ell)} of the absolute Galois group of FF. When the characteristic of kk is not ℓ\ell, Kummer theory identifies F×/F×ℓeF^\times/F^{\times\ell^e} with Hom⁡cont(ΠFa,μℓe)\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cont}}(\Pi_F^a, \mu_{\ell^e}) for every e≥1e \ge 1, and in the limit it identifies the completed multiplicative group Fˆ=lim←eF×/F×ℓe\widehat F = \underset{\longleftarrow}{\lim}_e F^\times/F^{\times\ell^e} with Hom⁡cont(ΠFa,ℤℓ(1))\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cont}}(\Pi_F^a, \mathbb{Z}_\ell(1)).

Each f∈F×f \in F^\times has a class [f][f] in Fˆ\widehat F, and the question is how faithfully Fˆ\widehat F records F×F^\times: does Fˆ\widehat F contain elements of finite order other than 11, and which ff have trivial class? In the rational function field k(t)k(t), for instance, is [t][t] trivial, and what becomes of the constants?

Power Classes and the Completion

The completion is defined for an arbitrary commutative group. Let GG be a commutative group, written multiplicatively, and qq a natural number. The subgroup of qqth powers GqG^q of GG is the subgroup {xq:x∈G}\{x^q : x \in G\}, the image of the homomorphism x↦xqx \mapsto x^q of GG to itself.✦ The group of power classes G/GqG/G^q is the quotient group of GG by GqG^q; its elements are the cosets xGqxG^q.✦ If rr is a natural number divisible by qq, the reduction ρr,q:G/Gr→G/Gq\rho_{r,q}\colon G/G^r \to G/G^q is the homomorphism xGr↦xGqxG^r \mapsto xG^q induced by the identity of GG.✦

The ℓ\ell-adic power completion Gˆ\widehat G of GG is the subgroup of the product ∏n≥0G/Gℓn\prod_{n \ge 0} G/G^{\ell^n} formed by the compatible families, Gˆ={(xn)n≥0∈∏n≥0G/Gℓn:ρℓn+1,ℓn(xn+1)=xn for every n≥0},\widehat G = \Bigl\{(x_n)_{n \ge 0} \in \prod_{n \ge 0} G/G^{\ell^n} : \rho_{\ell^{n+1},\ell^n}(x_{n+1}) = x_n \text{ for every } n \ge 0\Bigr\},(1) The class map G→GˆG \to \widehat G sends xx to the family of its power classes, [x]=(xGℓn)n≥0.[x] = \bigl(xG^{\ell^n}\bigr)_{n \ge 0}.(2)✦ For G=F×G = F^\times the completion (1) is Fˆ\widehat F, and (2) gives the class [f][f] of f∈F×f \in F^\times.

If FF is an extension of a field EE, the inclusion of units E×→F×E^\times \to F^\times is the homomorphism of unit groups induced by the embedding E→FE \to F.✦ For E=kE = k the image of the inclusion of units k×→F×k^\times \to F^\times is the group k×k^\times of constants of FF.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let ℓ\ell be a prime, kk an algebraically closed field and FF a field containing kk.

  1. If GG is a commutative group in which every zz with zℓ=1z^\ell = 1 lies in GℓnG^{\ell^n} for every n≥0n \ge 0, then {x∈Gˆ:xm=1 for some m≥1}={1}.\{x \in \widehat G : x^m = 1 \text{ for some } m \ge 1\} = \{1\}.(3)✦

  2. For every positive integer qq, the group μq(F)\mu_q(F) of qqth roots of unity in FF satisfies μq(F)⊆⋂n≥0F×qn.\mu_q(F) \subseteq \bigcap_{n \ge 0} F^{\times q^n}.(4)✦

  3. The completed multiplicative group of FF satisfies {x∈Fˆ:xm=1 for some m≥1}={1}.\{x \in \widehat F : x^m = 1 \text{ for some } m \ge 1\} = \{1\}.(5)✦

  4. If FF is a function field over kk, then {u∈F×:[u]=1}=k×,\{u \in F^\times : [u] = 1\} = k^\times,(6)✦ and every u∈F×u \in F^\times transcendental over kk satisfies [u]≠1.[u] \ne 1.(7)✦

In the paper, the result reads: F×/k×F^\times/k^\times is free abelian; hence WF=Hom⁡(F×,ℤℓ)W_F = \operatorname{Hom}(F^\times, \mathbb{Z}_\ell) is a product of copies of ℤℓ\mathbb{Z}_\ell, evaluation gives Fˆ=Hom⁡cont(WF,ℤℓ)\widehat F = \operatorname{Hom}_{\mathrm{cont}}(W_F, \mathbb{Z}_\ell) and Fˆ/ℓeFˆ=F×/F×ℓe\widehat F/\ell^e\widehat F = F^\times/F^{\times\ell^e}, Fˆ\widehat F is torsion-free, and evaluations on WFW_F detect every finite-level class.

What Is Checked

The claim is stated over the completion (1), the inverse limit of the groups of power classes G/GℓnG/G^{\ell^n} along the reductions, and over the class map (2); the fourth part also uses the inclusion of units k×→F×k^\times \to F^\times.

The library proves that the identity of GG induces a well-defined homomorphism ρr,q\rho_{r,q} whenever qq divides rr, and that the compatible families form a subgroup of ∏n≥0G/Gℓn\prod_{n \ge 0} G/G^{\ell^n}.