OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. The Hamiltonian counterexample

§6 (proof of Theorem 1.1): The fixed set of a midpoint perturbation on the projective quadric Q3Q^3 and a degenerate tangent at one of its points

Three fixed points and a horizontal kernel.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The projective quadric Q3Q^3 lies in ℂℙ4\mathbb{CP}^4. The set 𝒰\mathcal U of unit isotropic representatives of the projective quadric Q3Q^3 is the subset of ℂ5\mathbb C^5 defined in (1), where NN is the squared Hermitian norm and PP is the quadric form; projectivization is the map π(z)=[z]\pi(z)=[z].✦ N(z)=∑j=04|zj|2,P(z)=∑j=04zj2,Q3={[z]∈ℂℙ4:P(z)=0},𝒰={z∈ℂ5:N(z)=1,P(z)=0}.\begin{gathered} N(z)=\sum_{j=0}^4|z_j|^2,\qquad P(z)=\sum_{j=0}^4z_j^2,\\ Q^3=\{[z]\in\mathbb{CP}^4:P(z)=0\},\qquad \mathcal U=\{z\in\mathbb C^5:N(z)=1,\ P(z)=0\}. \end{gathered}(1)

A horizontal tangent vector ww at z∈𝒰z\in\mathcal U is a vector of ℂ5\mathbb C^5 belonging to the subspace ℋz\mathcal H_z defined in (2). The symplectic normalization on horizontal vectors is also fixed there. ℋz={w∈ℂ5:∑j=04zj¯wj=0,∑j=04zjwj=0},ω(w,u)=2Im⁡∑j=04wj¯uj.\mathcal H_z= \left\{w\in\mathbb C^5: \sum_{j=0}^4\overline{z_j}w_j=0,\quad \sum_{j=0}^4z_jw_j=0\right\},\qquad \omega(w,u)=2\operatorname{Im}\sum_{j=0}^4\overline{w_j}u_j.(2)

A degenerate fixed point q∈Q3q\in Q^3 of an automorphism ψ\psi of Q3Q^3 is a fixed point represented by some z∈𝒰z\in\mathcal U that admits a nonzero w∈ℋzw\in\mathcal H_z with the following property. There is a map L:ℂ5→ℂ5L:\mathbb C^5\to\mathbb C^5, smooth on an open neighborhood VV of zz, that fixes zz, maps V∩𝒰V\cap\mathcal U into 𝒰\mathcal U, and satisfies [L(y)]=ψ([y])[L(y)]=\psi([y]) for every y∈V∩𝒰y\in V\cap\mathcal U, with derivative as in (3). dLz(w)−w∈ℝiz.dL_z(w)-w\in\mathbb R\,iz.(3)

The Truncated Field

The oriented plane coordinates mabm_{ab} on ℂ5\mathbb C^5 and the self-dual and anti-self-dual sphere factors x,y:ℂ5→ℝ3x,y:\mathbb C^5\to\mathbb R^3 are defined by (4). mab(z)=2Im⁡(za¯zb),0≤a,b≤4,x(z)=(m12+m34,m13−m24,m14+m23)(z),y(z)=(m12−m34,m13+m24,m14−m23)(z).\begin{aligned} m_{ab}(z)&=2\operatorname{Im}(\overline{z_a}z_b),\qquad 0\leq a,b\leq4,\\ x(z)&=(m_{12}+m_{34},\ m_{13}-m_{24},\ m_{14}+m_{23})(z),\\ y(z)&=(m_{12}-m_{34},\ m_{13}+m_{24},\ m_{14}-m_{23})(z). \end{aligned}(4)

Let eje_j be the coordinate vectors of ℂ5\mathbb C^5. The coordinate plane rotation generators JabJ_{ab} are real-linear operators, and the self-dual and anti-self-dual infinitesimal rotations Ai,BiA_i,B_i, indexed by i=0,1,2i=0,1,2, are the operators in (5). Jabw=waeb−wbea,(A0,A1,A2)=(J12+J34,J13−J24,J14+J23),(B0,B1,B2)=(J12−J34,J13+J24,J14−J23).\begin{gathered} J_{ab}w=w_a e_b-w_b e_a,\\ (A_0,A_1,A_2)=(J_{12}+J_{34},\ J_{13}-J_{24},\ J_{14}+J_{23}),\\ (B_0,B_1,B_2)=(J_{12}-J_{34},\ J_{13}+J_{24},\ J_{14}-J_{23}). \end{gathered}(5)

The self-dual Casimir cc and the sphere factor pairing aa are real functions on ℂ5\mathbb C^5. The self-dual radial field SS and mixed sphere field TT on ℂ5\mathbb C^5 are the vector fields defined in (6). c(z)=|x(z)|2,a(z)=x(z)⋅y(z),S(z)=∑i=02xi(z)Aiz,T(z)=∑i=02(yi(z)Aiz+xi(z)Biz).\begin{gathered} c(z)=|x(z)|^2,\qquad a(z)=x(z)\cdot y(z),\\ S(z)=\sum_{i=0}^2x_i(z)A_i z,\qquad T(z)=\sum_{i=0}^2\bigl(y_i(z)A_i z+x_i(z)B_i z\bigr). \end{gathered}(6)

Choose a smooth inverse square root extension b:ℝ→ℝb:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R agreeing with s−1/2s^{-1/2} on [1/32,32][1/32,32].✦ Let χ:ℝ→ℝ\chi:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R be the smooth radial bump function centered at zero, equal to one for |s|≤4|s|\leq4 and zero for |s|≥8|s|\geq8.✦ The uncut Hamiltonian field X0X_0 and the truncated Hamiltonian field XX are the vector fields on ℂ5\mathbb C^5 in (7); for a Hamiltonian HH, the convention is ιXω=dH\iota_X\omega=dH. X0(z)=A0z−B2z+b(c(z))T(z)+2b′(c(z))a(z)S(z),X(z)=χ(N(z))X0(z).\begin{aligned} X_0(z)&=A_0z-B_2z+b(c(z))T(z)+2b'(c(z))a(z)S(z),\\ X(z)&=\chi(N(z))X_0(z). \end{aligned}(7)

The Midpoint Perturbation

For a CYC_Y-Lipschitz vector field Y:E→EY:E\to E on a real normed vector space and a step function σ:ℝ→ℝ\sigma:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R satisfying |σ(t)|CY<1|\sigma(t)|C_Y<1 at every time, the nonlinear resolvent rtY,σ(z)r^{Y,\sigma}_t(z) is the unique solution of the first equation in (8).✦ For a vector field Y:E→EY:E\to E and a step function σ:ℝ→ℝ\sigma:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R satisfying the contraction bound, the implicit midpoint step MtY,σM^{Y,\sigma}_t is the map from EE to EE given by the second equation in (8), with actual step size 2σ(t)2\sigma(t). rtY,σ(z)=z+σ(t)Y(rtY,σ(z)),MtY,σ(z)=2rtY,σ(z)−z.r^{Y,\sigma}_t(z)=z+\sigma(t)Y(r^{Y,\sigma}_t(z)),\qquad M^{Y,\sigma}_t(z)=2r^{Y,\sigma}_t(z)-z.(8)

Choose a nonnegative global Lipschitz constant CC for XX. For the chosen Lipschitz constant CC of XX, the step scale ε\varepsilon is the real number and the step parameter τ\tau is the function from ℝ\mathbb R to ℝ\mathbb R given in (9). ε=1100(C+1),τ(t)=εsin⁡πt2.\varepsilon=\frac{1}{100(C+1)},\qquad \tau(t)=\varepsilon\sin\frac{\pi t}{2}.(9)

For real c1,s1c_1,s_1, the simultaneous planar rotation R(c1,s1)R(c_1,s_1) and the rotation isotopy RtR_t are the maps of ℂ5\mathbb C^5 in (10). R(c1,s1)z=(z0,c1z1−s1z2,s1z1+c1z2,c1z3−s1z4,s1z3+c1z4),Rt=R(cos⁡(πt),sin⁡(πt)).\begin{aligned} R(c_1,s_1)z &=(z_0,\ c_1z_1-s_1z_2,\ s_1z_1+c_1z_2, \ c_1z_3-s_1z_4,\ s_1z_3+c_1z_4),\\ R_t&=R(\cos(\pi t),\sin(\pi t)). \end{aligned}(10)

The forward and backward midpoint maps Mt+,Mt−M_t^+,M_t^- and the maps Ft,F̃tF_t,\widetilde F_t of the lifted isotopy and its inverse are the maps from ℂ5\mathbb C^5 to ℂ5\mathbb C^5 defined in (11). Mt+=MtX,τ,Mt−=MtX,−τ,Ft=Rt∘Mt+,F̃t=Mt−∘R−t.M_t^+=M^{X,\tau}_t,\qquad M_t^-=M^{X,-\tau}_t,\qquad F_t=R_t\circ M_t^+,\qquad \widetilde F_t=M_t^-\circ R_{-t}.(11)

For a map FF preserving 𝒰\mathcal U, its induced quotient map on Q3Q^3 is the map that sends a point q∈Q3q\in Q^3 to [F(s(q))][F(s(q))], where s(q)∈𝒰s(q)\in\mathcal U is a chosen unit representative of qq.✦ Two such maps that are inverse on 𝒰\mathcal U and equivariant under multiplication by unit complex numbers induce a quotient automorphism.✦ The perturbed quadric map φ\varphi from Q3Q^3 to Q3Q^3 and the phase-normalized lift GG from ℂ5\mathbb C^5 to ℂ5\mathbb C^5 are the maps defined in (12). φ(q)=[F1(s(q))],φ−1(q)=[F̃1(s(q))],G(w)=−F1(w).\varphi(q)=[F_1(s(q))],\qquad \varphi^{-1}(q)=[\widetilde F_1(s(q))],\qquad G(w)=-F_1(w).(12)

The distinguished vectors z0,z+,z−∈ℂ5z_0,z_+,z_-\in\mathbb C^5, the auxiliary vector family z(r)∈ℂ5z(r)\in\mathbb C^5 for r∈ℝr\in\mathbb R, and the projective classes q0,q+,q−q_0,q_+,q_- are defined in (13). z0=(0,12,−i2,12,i2),z(r)=(0,1+r4,i2,1−r4,−i2),z+=z(3),z−=z(−3),q0=[z0],q+=[z+],q−=[z−].\begin{gathered} z_0=\left(0,\frac12,-\frac i2,\frac12,\frac i2\right),\qquad z(r)=\left(0,\frac{1+r}{4},\frac i2,\frac{1-r}{4},-\frac i2\right),\\ z_+=z(\sqrt3),\qquad z_-=z(-\sqrt3),\qquad q_0=[z_0],\quad q_+=[z_+],\quad q_-=[z_-]. \end{gathered}(13) The positive fixed point lift z+∈𝒰z_+\in\mathcal U is the unit isotropic representative of q+q_+ obtained from the auxiliary vector family at the nonnegative square root of 33.✦ The negative fixed point lift z−∈𝒰z_-\in\mathcal U is the unit isotropic representative of q−q_- obtained from the auxiliary vector family at the negative of the nonnegative square root of 33.✦

The kernel vector v∈ℂ5v\in\mathbb C^5 is the vector in (14). v=(0,−14,i4,14,i4).v=\left(0,-\frac14,\frac i4,\frac14,\frac i4\right).(14)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. For the perturbed quadric automorphism φ\varphi of (12), the complete fixed set is given by (15). Fix⁡(φ)={q0,q+,q−}.\operatorname{Fix}(\varphi)=\{q_0,q_+,q_-\}.(15)✦ The kernel vector at z0z_0 satisfies (16) and (17). v≠0.v\ne0.(16)✦ v∈ℋz0.v\in\mathcal H_{z_0}.(17)✦ For the truncated field, the identities are (18) and (19), with derivatives over ℝ\mathbb R. X(z0)=0.X(z_0)=0.(18)✦ dXz0(v)=0.dX_{z_0}(v)=0.(19)✦ More generally, let Y:E→EY:E\to E be a smooth CYC_Y-Lipschitz vector field on a real Banach space EE, and let σ:ℝ→ℝ\sigma:\mathbb R\to\mathbb R be smooth with |σ(s)|CY<1|\sigma(s)|C_Y<1 for every ss. For z,w∈Ez,w\in E satisfying Y(z)=0Y(z)=0 and dYz(w)=0dY_z(w)=0, the midpoint derivative satisfies (20) at every real time tt. d(MtY,σ)z(w)=w.d(M^{Y,\sigma}_t)_z(w)=w.(20)✦ The phase-normalized lift has the differential in (21). dGz0(v)=v.dG_{z_0}(v)=v.(21)✦ φ has a degenerate fixed point.\varphi\text{ has a degenerate fixed point.}(22)✦

In the paper, the result reads: the three critical points q0,q+,q−q_0,q_+,q_- of the Hamiltonian restricted to the surface fixed by the projective rotation induced by R1R_1 give all fixed points of φ\varphi, and at q0q_0 a nonzero tangent vector in the kernel of the Hessian of that restriction is fixed by dφd\varphi, giving a degenerate Hamiltonian fixed point.

What Is Checked

The statements concern the quotient automorphism (12) of the literal quadric (1), with the real derivative of the truncated field (7). Projectivization from 𝒰\mathcal U is surjective✦, and z0z_0 satisfies the unit isotropic condition.✦

The step parameter obeys the contraction bound (23). For any step function satisfying a contraction bound, its negative satisfies the same bound.✦ |τ(t)|C<1(t∈ℝ).|\tau(t)|C<1\qquad(t\in\mathbb R).(23)✦

The time-one lifts F1F_1 and F̃1\widetilde F_1 are inverse maps of 𝒰\mathcal U and are equivariant under multiplication by every complex number of modulus one.