OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. The rigidity obstruction

Proposition 6.3: For a locally nilpotent determinant derivation EE with nonpositive fiber shift and the principalizing element vv, E2(v)=0E^2(v)=0 forces vanishing

A rigidity criterion for determinant derivations.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let C=ℂC=\mathbb C. The determinant cylinder is the affine hypersurface ac−bd=1ac-bd=1 with a free coordinate uu. The question concerns locally nilpotent CC-derivations of its coordinate algebra, homogeneous for a fiber weight, and their second iterate on a distinguished element.

The determinant polynomial ring PP, its defining polynomial ff and the determinant algebra TT are given by (1). P=C[a,d,b,c,u],f=ac−bd−1,T=P/(f).P=C[a,d,b,c,u],\qquad f=ac-bd-1,\qquad T=P/(f).(1) The determinant quotient map π:P→T\pi:P\to T is the canonical CC-algebra homomorphism sending a polynomial to its residue class modulo ff.✦ The matrix coordinates a,d,b,c∈Ta,d,b,c\in T and the cylinder coordinate u∈Tu\in T are the residue classes of the corresponding polynomial variables.

The principalizing element v∈Tv\in T is the element defined by (2). v=a3b−a2u3−d2.v=a^3b-a^2u^3-d^2.(2)✦

Derivations and Weights

Let RR be a CC-algebra, DD a CC-derivation of RR and I⊆RI\subseteq R an ideal satisfying D(I)⊆ID(I)\subseteq I. If q:R→R/Iq:R\to R/I is the residue map, the induced quotient derivation D¯\overline D is the CC-linear map on R/IR/I specified by (3). D¯(q(r))=q(D(r))(r∈R).\overline D\bigl(q(r)\bigr)=q\bigl(D(r)\bigr)\qquad(r\in R).(3)✦

The polynomial unipotent derivations δP,ηP\delta_P,\eta_P of PP are the CC-derivations in (4). Their induced quotient derivations on TT are denoted by δ\delta and η\eta, respectively. δP=a∂∂b+d∂∂c,ηP=b∂∂a+c∂∂d.\delta_P=a\frac{\partial}{\partial b}+d\frac{\partial}{\partial c}, \qquad \eta_P=b\frac{\partial}{\partial a}+c\frac{\partial}{\partial d}.(4)

For operators S1,S2S_1,S_2, write [S1,S2]=S1∘S2−S2∘S1[S_1,S_2]=S_1\circ S_2-S_2\circ S_1. The fiber Euler derivation Euler\mathrm{Euler} of TT is the commutator specified in (5), with the indicated coordinate weights. Euler=[δ,η],(Euler(a),Euler(d),Euler(b),Euler(c),Euler(u))=(a,d,−b,−c,0).\begin{gathered} \mathrm{Euler}=[\delta,\eta],\\ \bigl(\mathrm{Euler}(a),\mathrm{Euler}(d),\mathrm{Euler}(b), \mathrm{Euler}(c),\mathrm{Euler}(u)\bigr)=(a,d,-b,-c,0). \end{gathered}(5)✦ A CC-derivation EE of TT has fiber weight shift e∈ℤe\in\mathbb Z when the operator identity (6) holds. [Euler,E]=eE.[\mathrm{Euler},E]=eE.(6)✦ Commutation with the fiber Euler operator is the case e=0e=0 in (6).

The auxiliary coordinate weight ω\omega is the integer assignment to the ordered coordinates of PP given by (7). (ω(a),ω(d),ω(b),ω(c),ω(u))=(0,3,−3,0,2).\bigl(\omega(a),\omega(d),\omega(b),\omega(c),\omega(u)\bigr) =(0,3,-3,0,2).(7)✦

For a coefficient ring kk, a kk-linear derivation DD of a kk-algebra RR is locally nilpotent if every r∈Rr\in R is killed by some nonnegative iterate of DD, as in (8); the exponent denotes iteration. For every r∈R,Dn(r)=0 for some n∈ℤ≥0.\text{For every }r\in R,\quad D^n(r)=0\text{ for some }n\in\mathbb Z_{\geq 0}.(8)✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let EE be a locally nilpotent CC-derivation of TT with fiber weight shift e∈ℤe\in\mathbb Z, where e≤0e\leq 0. If E2(v)=0E^2(v)=0, then (9) holds. E=0.E=0.(9)✦

Let EE be a locally nilpotent CC-derivation of TT with fiber weight shift e∈ℤe\in\mathbb Z, where e≤0e\leq 0. If EE fixes a,d,ua,d,u, then (10) holds. E=0.E=0.(10)✦

Let δ0,η0,H0\delta_0,\eta_0,H_0 be CC-linear endomorphisms of a complex vector space RR satisfying [δ0,η0]=H0[\delta_0,\eta_0]=H_0 and [H0,η0]=−2η0[H_0,\eta_0]=-2\eta_0. Suppose r∈Rr\in R satisfies δ0r=0\delta_0r=0 and H0r=wrH_0r=wr for an integer w<0w<0, and that η0n(r)=0\eta_0^n(r)=0 for some nonnegative integer nn. Then (11) holds. r=0.r=0.(11)✦

What Is Checked

The determinant statements concern CC-derivations of the presented algebra TT with local nilpotence and an integral nonpositive fiber shift; the highest-weight statement concerns CC-linear endomorphisms with the stated commutator identities.

The induced quotient linear map in (3) satisfies the Leibniz identity (12). D¯(q(r)q(s))=q(r)D¯(q(s))+q(s)D¯(q(r))(r,s∈R).\overline D\bigl(q(r)q(s)\bigr) =q(r)\overline D\bigl(q(s)\bigr) +q(s)\overline D\bigl(q(r)\bigr)\qquad(r,s\in R).(12) The determinant ideal (f)(f) is invariant under both polynomial unipotent derivations, with the annihilation identities in (13). δP(f)=0,ηP(f)=0.\delta_P(f)=0,\qquad \eta_P(f)=0.(13)