OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §6. The rigidity obstruction

Proof of Proposition 6.3: polynomial orbits and the nonsquare: A square-cube sum of degree at most one and its consequence for locally nilpotent derivations

Rigidity under a nonsquare condition.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let CC be the field of complex numbers. The determinant cylinder ac−bd=1ac-bd=1 in affine five-space over CC has coordinates a,d,b,c,ua,d,b,c,u. The rigidity question asks whether a locally nilpotent derivation can move a,d,ua,d,u while its second iterate kills d2+a2u3d^2+a^2u^3.

The determinant polynomial ring is P=C[a,d,b,c,u]P=C[a,d,b,c,u]✦, and its determinant equation is r=ac−bd−1r=ac-bd-1.✦ The determinant algebra TT is the quotient of PP by the principal ideal (r)(r), with canonical quotient homomorphism π\pi as in (1): T=P/(r),π:P→T,h↦h+(r).T=P/(r),\qquad \pi:P\longrightarrow T,\qquad h\longmapsto h+(r).(1) The same coordinate letters denote their residue classes in TT; in particular, the cylinder coordinate is u=π(u)u=\pi(u).✦

The coefficient polynomial ring SS and the base polynomial ring BB, together with the coefficient fraction field K0K_0 and rational function field KK, are defined by (2), where tt is an indeterminate over K0K_0: S=C[a,d,b],B=C[u,a,d,b],K0=Frac⁡(S),K=K0(t).S=C[a,d,b],\qquad B=C[u,a,d,b],\qquad K_0=\operatorname{Frac}(S),\qquad K=K_0(t).(2) The base algebra embedding β:B→K\beta:B\longrightarrow K is the CC-algebra homomorphism specified in (3): β(u)=t,β(a)=a,β(d)=d,β(b)=b.\beta(u)=t,\qquad \beta(a)=a,\qquad \beta(d)=d,\qquad \beta(b)=b.(3)✦ The determinant evaluation ev⁡:P→K\operatorname{ev}:P\longrightarrow K is the CC-algebra homomorphism with the rational coordinate tuple in (4); the determinant algebra map ι:T→K\iota:T\longrightarrow K is its induced homomorphism: (ev⁡(a),ev⁡(d),ev⁡(b),ev⁡(c),ev⁡(u))=(a,d,b,1+bda,t),ι∘π=ev⁡.\bigl(\operatorname{ev}(a),\operatorname{ev}(d),\operatorname{ev}(b), \operatorname{ev}(c),\operatorname{ev}(u)\bigr) =\left(a,d,b,\frac{1+bd}{a},t\right),\qquad \iota\circ\pi=\operatorname{ev}.(4)

Let kk be a field. A kk-linear derivation DD of a commutative kk-algebra RR is locally nilpotent if every element of RR is killed by an iterate of DD, as in (5): for every h∈R there is m≥0 with Dm(h)=0.\text{for every }h\in R\text{ there is }m\geq0\text{ with }D^m(h)=0.(5)✦

For polynomial orbits, qq denotes the orbit parameter and kk a field; the letters a,d,u,na,d,u,n then denote polynomials in k[q]k[q]. For a polynomial ff in k[q]k[q], write rad⁡(f)\operatorname{rad}(f) for its polynomial radical, and take the degree of the zero polynomial to be zero.

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let a,d,u,n∈k[q]a,d,u,n\in k[q]. If n≠0n\ne0, deg⁡n≤1\deg n\leq1, and d2+a2u3=nd^2+a^2u^3=n, then gcd⁡(d2,a2u3)=1.\gcd\bigl(d^2,a^2u^3\bigr)=1.(6)✦ For arbitrary a,d,u,n∈k[q]a,d,u,n\in k[q], the radical satisfies deg⁡rad⁡(d2(a2u3)(−n))≤deg⁡d+deg⁡a+deg⁡u+deg⁡n.\deg\operatorname{rad}\bigl(d^2(a^2u^3)(-n)\bigr) \leq\deg d+\deg a+\deg u+\deg n.(7)✦ Suppose further that kk has characteristic zero, that a,d,u,na,d,u,n are nonzero, that deg⁡n≤1\deg n\leq1 and d2+a2u3=nd^2+a^2u^3=n, and that −u(0)3-u(0)^3 is not a square in kk. Then a=a(0),d=d(0),u=u(0).a=a(0),\qquad d=d(0),\qquad u=u(0).(8)✦ Let LL be a field, let tt be an indeterminate over LL, and let z∈L(t)z\in L(t). Then z2≠−t3.z^2\ne-t^3.(9)✦ For the determinant algebra map ι:T→K\iota:T\longrightarrow K and every z∈Kz\in K, z2≠−ι(u)3.z^2\ne-\iota(u)^3.(10)✦ Let kk be a field of characteristic zero, let RR be a commutative kk-algebra, and let f:R→Lf:R\longrightarrow L be an injective kk-algebra homomorphism into a field LL. Let DD be a locally nilpotent kk-linear derivation of RR, and let a,d,u∈Ra,d,u\in R be nonzero. Suppose that d2+a2u3≠0d^2+a^2u^3\ne0, that D2(d2+a2u3)=0D^2(d^2+a^2u^3)=0, and that −f(u)3-f(u)^3 is not a square in LL. Then D(a)=0,D(d)=0,D(u)=0.D(a)=0,\qquad D(d)=0,\qquad D(u)=0.(11)✦

In the paper, the result reads: for N=d2+a2u3N=d^2+a^2u^3, a locally nilpotent derivation E′E' with E′2(N)=0E'^2(N)=0 has a polynomial orbit sum d(q)2+a(q)2u(q)3d(q)^2+a(q)^2u(q)^3 of degree at most one, and polynomial abc together with the nonsquareness of −u3-u^3 in the original fraction field forces E′(a)=E′(d)=E′(u)=0E'(a)=E'(d)=E'(u)=0.

What Is Checked

The polynomial assertions (6), (7), (8), and (9) are stated over fields, with characteristic zero required in (8); the derivation assertion (11) concerns an algebra with an injective map into a field, whereas (10) is stated for TT and its map ι\iota in (4). The determinant evaluation annihilates the principal ideal (ac−bd−1)(ac-bd-1) and therefore descends to the homomorphism ι:T→K\iota:T\longrightarrow K.