OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §5. Extracting a derivation on the determinant ring

Proposition 5.2: The valuation grading and fiber Euler operator impose different conditions on derivations of the pullback algebra

Extracting coefficient derivations of nonpositive shift.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

Let CC be the complex field. The determinant algebra TT is the coordinate algebra of ac−bd=1ac-bd=1 with an additional cylinder coordinate uu.✦ Its polynomial ring QQ, quotient map πdet\pi_{\mathrm{det}}, and principalizing element vv are given by (1); the letters a,d,b,c,ua,d,b,c,u also denote their residue classes. Q=C[a,d,b,c,u],T=Q/(ac−bd−1),πdet:Q→T,v=a3b−a2u3−d2∈T.\begin{gathered} Q=C[a,d,b,c,u],\qquad T=Q/(ac-bd-1),\qquad \pi_{\mathrm{det}}:Q\longrightarrow T,\\ v=a^3b-a^2u^3-d^2\in T. \end{gathered}(1) The defining polynomial of the determinant equation is ac−bd−1∈Qac-bd-1\in Q.✦

The affine algebra AA in the cancellation question is defined using the polynomial coordinates p,s,u,F,Jp,s,u,F,J by (2). x=s2+u3+p2F,H=x2F−(1+2sx)J−p2J2−pu,A=C[p,s,u,F,J]/(H).\begin{gathered} x=s^2+u^3+p^2F,\\ H=x^2F-(1+2sx)J-p^2J^2-pu,\qquad A=C[p,s,u,F,J]/(H). \end{gathered}(2)

For an integral CC-algebra RR and an element v∈Rv\in R, the affine modification 𝒯(R,v)\mathcal T(R,v) is the quotient in (3).✦ Here PRP_R is the modification polynomial ring, fvf_v is its defining equation, and πv\pi_v is the quotient homomorphism. The modification coordinate VV is the residue class of the polynomial coordinate VV, and the same convention applies to τ\tau.✦ PR=R[τ,V],fv=τ2V−v,𝒯(R,v)=PR/(fv),πv:PR→𝒯(R,v).P_R=R[\tau,V],\qquad f_v=\tau^2V-v,\qquad \mathcal T(R,v)=P_R/(f_v),\qquad \pi_v:P_R\longrightarrow\mathcal T(R,v).(3) The pullback algebra is B=𝒯(T,v)B=\mathcal T(T,v), with TT and vv as in (1).✦

Valuation Degree and Fiber Weight

For e∈ℤe\in\mathbb Z, the weighted homogeneous submodule PR,eP_{R,e} of PRP_R consists of the polynomials of valuation degree ee, with coefficient degree zero and weights −1,2-1,2 on τ,V\tau,V.✦ The valuation homogeneous component 𝒯e(R,v)\mathcal T_e(R,v) of 𝒯(R,v)\mathcal T(R,v) is the image of PR,eP_{R,e} under πv\pi_v, as in (4). PR,e=⨁i,m≥02m−i=eRτiVm,𝒯e(R,v)=πv(PR,e),Be=𝒯e(T,v).P_{R,e}=\bigoplus_{\substack{i,m\geq 0\\2m-i=e}}R\tau^iV^m, \qquad \mathcal T_e(R,v)=\pi_v(P_{R,e}),\qquad B_e=\mathcal T_e(T,v).(4) The spaces BeB_e are regarded as CC-linear subspaces of BB. A derivation DD of 𝒯(R,v)\mathcal T(R,v) has valuation shift j∈ℤj\in\mathbb Z if it sends 𝒯e(R,v)\mathcal T_e(R,v) into 𝒯e+j(R,v)\mathcal T_{e+j}(R,v) for every integer ee.

For a CC-derivation DD of a CC-algebra RR and prescribed polynomials di∈R[zi∣i∈I]d_i\in R[z_i\mid i\in I], the polynomial derivation extension D̃\widetilde D is the CC-derivation of R[zi∣i∈I]R[z_i\mid i\in I] that restricts to DD on RR and sends each ziz_i to did_i.✦

Let ℋ\mathcal H be a CC-derivation of RR satisfying ℋ(v)=2v\mathcal H(v)=2v. The polynomial Euler extension ℋP\mathcal H_P of ℋ\mathcal H is the CC-derivation of PRP_R that restricts to ℋ\mathcal H on RR and has the coordinate values in (5).✦ The polynomial Euler extension ℋP\mathcal H_P preserves the defining ideal (fv)(f_v). The induced quotient derivation ℋˆ\widehat{\mathcal H} of 𝒯(R,v)\mathcal T(R,v) is the CC-derivation specified on residue classes in (5). ℋP|R=ℋ,ℋP(τ)=0,ℋP(V)=2V,ℋˆ(πv(f))=πv(ℋP(f))(f∈PR).\begin{gathered} \mathcal H_P|_R=\mathcal H,\qquad \mathcal H_P(\tau)=0,\qquad \mathcal H_P(V)=2V,\\ \widehat{\mathcal H}(\pi_v(f))=\pi_v(\mathcal H_P(f)) \quad(f\in P_R). \end{gathered}(5)

On QQ, the polynomial unipotent derivations δQ,ηQ\delta_Q,\eta_Q have the coordinate values in (6). Their induced quotient derivations on TT are denoted by δ,η\delta,\eta. δQ(a,d,b,c,u)=(0,0,a,d,0),ηQ(a,d,b,c,u)=(b,c,0,0,0).\begin{aligned} \delta_Q(a,d,b,c,u)&=(0,0,a,d,0),\\ \eta_Q(a,d,b,c,u)&=(b,c,0,0,0). \end{aligned}(6) The determinant fiber Euler derivation Euler\mathrm{Euler} of TT is the CC-derivation given by Euler=[δ,η]=δ∘η−η∘δ\mathrm{Euler}=[\delta,\eta]=\delta\circ\eta-\eta\circ\delta.✦ The fiber Euler derivation EulerB\mathrm{Euler}_B of BB is the extension of Euler\mathrm{Euler} with the coordinate values in (7). EulerB(a,d,b,c,u,τ,V)=(a,d,−b,−c,0,0,2V).\mathrm{Euler}_B(a,d,b,c,u,\tau,V)=(a,d,-b,-c,0,0,2V).(7)✦ A derivation EE of TT has integer fiber shift qq if [Euler,E]=qE[\mathrm{Euler},E]=qE; on BB the definition uses EulerB\mathrm{Euler}_B.

A CC-derivation DD of a CC-algebra SS is locally nilpotent if every r∈Sr\in S is annihilated by some nonnegative iterate DnD^n.✦

The Claim

Theorem 1. Let RR be an integral CC-algebra and v∈Rv\in R. Suppose that DD is a locally nilpotent CC-derivation of 𝒯(R,v)\mathcal T(R,v) and that ww is a nonzero element of 𝒯e(R,v)\mathcal T_e(R,v) for some e>0e>0, with D(w)=0D(w)=0. Then the fixed-coordinate identity (8) holds. D(V)=0.D(V)=0.(8)✦

Let ℋ\mathcal H be a CC-derivation of RR with ℋ(v)=2v\mathcal H(v)=2v. Suppose that D≠0D\neq 0 is a locally nilpotent CC-derivation of 𝒯(R,v)\mathcal T(R,v) of integer valuation shift, commuting with ℋˆ\widehat{\mathcal H} and satisfying D(V)=0D(V)=0. There exist a nonzero locally nilpotent CC-derivation EE of RR and a nonnegative integer nn satisfying (9). [ℋ,E]=−nE,E2(v)=0.[\mathcal H,E]=-nE,\qquad E^2(v)=0.(9)✦

On BB, let D≠0D\neq 0 be a locally nilpotent CC-derivation of integer valuation shift that commutes with EulerB\mathrm{Euler}_B. For each positive integer ee, its kernel satisfies (10). ker⁡D∩Be={0}.\ker D\cap B_e=\{0\}.(10)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if AA is isomorphic as a CC-algebra to the four-variable polynomial ring, then TT, denoted R̃\widetilde R there, admits a nonzero locally nilpotent CC-derivation EE of integer fiber shift q≤0q\leq 0 satisfying E2(v)=0E^2(v)=0.

What Is Checked

The statements concern CC-linear derivations of an integral coefficient algebra RR and its affine modification, with BB the determinant specialization carrying the valuation pieces and fiber Euler derivation defined above. The determinant Euler derivation has the weight-two action on the principalizing element recorded in (11). Euler(v)=2v.\mathrm{Euler}(v)=2v.(11)✦