OctoInformBeta

OpenAI preprint, September 2026 · §3. A smooth degeneration and its derivations

Proposition 3.4: A nonzero locally nilpotent derivation on the presented degeneration fixes a nonzero element of positive valuation degree

Polynomiality forces a positive homogeneous invariant.

Hover over a blue or green term in the text, or a node in the graph, to find it in the other. Select it to read its declaration both in Lean and in words.

The Setting

The question concerns homogeneous invariant functions for locally nilpotent derivations on a degeneration of an affine hypersurface. Let C=ℂC=\mathbb C and let P=C[p,s,u,F,J]P=C[p,s,u,F,J] be the polynomial ring in the indicated ordered coordinates.✦ The hypersurface algebra AA, its auxiliary polynomial x∈Px\in P and its defining equation H∈PH\in P are given by (1): x=s2+u3+p2F,H=x2F−(1+2sx)J−p2J2−pu,A=C[p,s,u,F,J]/(H).\begin{gathered} x=s^2+u^3+p^2F,\qquad H=x^2F-(1+2sx)J-p^2J^2-pu,\\ A=C[p,s,u,F,J]/(H). \end{gathered}(1)

The degeneration algebra GG is the directly presented quotient in (2): Htop=x2F−(1+2sx)J−p2J2,G=P/(Htop).H_{\mathrm{top}}=x^2F-(1+2sx)J-p^2J^2,\qquad G=P/(H_{\mathrm{top}}).(2) The canonical quotient maps are α:P→A\alpha:P\to A and π:P→G\pi:P\to G. For q∈Pq\in P, write q‾=α(q)\bar q=\alpha(q); the coordinate names p,s,u,F,Jp,s,u,F,J in GG mean their images under π\pi. The defining degeneration equation Htop∈PH_{\mathrm{top}}\in P is the polynomial in (2).

Give PP the valuation weights in (3): (deg⁡p,deg⁡s,deg⁡u,deg⁡F,deg⁡J)=(−1,0,0,2,2).(\deg p,\deg s,\deg u,\deg F,\deg J)=(-1,0,0,2,2).(3)✦ For i∈ℤi\in\mathbb Z, the weighted homogeneous subspace Pi⊆PP_i\subseteq P consists of the polynomials all of whose monomials have valuation degree ii.✦ The homogeneous component Gi⊆GG_i\subseteq G is the image subspace defined by (4): Gi=π(Pi).G_i=\pi(P_i).(4)✦

A CC-derivation D:S→SD:S\to S of a CC-algebra SS is locally nilpotent when it satisfies (5), where DnD^n denotes nn successive applications of DD: for every r∈S there is n∈ℕ such that Dn(r)=0.\text{for every }r\in S\text{ there is }n\in\mathbb N \text{ such that }D^n(r)=0.(5)✦ An invariant rr of a derivation D:S→SD:S\to S is an element of SS belonging to ker⁡D\ker D.

The Rees Algebra

Let R=C[τ,p,s,u,F,J]R=C[\tau,p,s,u,F,J] be the polynomial ring in six variables, and let xB∈Rx_B\in R be the polynomial xx of (1), read in these coordinates. The Rees algebra BB is the hypersurface quotient in (6): ℋ=xB2F−(1+2sxB)J−p2J2−τ3pu,B=R/(ℋ).\mathcal H=x_B^2F-(1+2sx_B)J-p^2J^2-\tau^3pu,\qquad B=R/(\mathcal H).(6) The Rees defining equation ℋ∈R\mathcal H\in R is the polynomial in (6).

The Laurent algebra L=A[t,t−1]L=A[t,t^{-1}] has coefficient inclusion c:A→Lc:A\to L, which sends an element of AA to its constant Laurent polynomial. For a coordinate q∈{p,s,u,F,J}q\in\{p,s,u,F,J\}, write aq=c(q‾)a_q=c(\bar q). The Rees evaluation R→LR\to L is the substitution in (7); the induced CC-algebra homomorphism ι:B→L\iota:B\to L is the Rees embedding: (τ,p,s,u,F,J)↦(t,apt−1,as,au,aFt2,aJt2).(\tau,p,s,u,F,J)\longmapsto (t,a_p t^{-1},a_s,a_u,a_Ft^2,a_Jt^2).(7) The scaled coordinate tuple is the ordered sextuple in L6L^6 on the right side of (7). For each coordinate q∈{p,s,u,F,J}q\in\{p,s,u,F,J\}, its Laurent coefficient aq∈La_q\in L is the image of its residue class in AA under the coefficient inclusion cc.

The special fiber evaluation R→GR\to G is the substitution in (8).✦ The special fiber reduction ρ:B→G\rho:B\to G is the CC-algebra homomorphism induced by the substitution in (8): (τ,p,s,u,F,J)↦(0,p,s,u,F,J).(\tau,p,s,u,F,J)\longmapsto(0,p,s,u,F,J).(8) The special fiber coordinate tuple is the ordered sextuple in G6G^6 on the right side of (8).

The Claim

Theorem 1. The Laurent coefficient of the coordinate FF satisfies (9): c(F‾)∉ι(B).c(\bar F)\notin\iota(B).(9)✦ For r∈Ar\in A with c(r)∉ι(B)c(r)\notin\iota(B), there are an integer ii and an element b∈Bb\in B satisfying (10): i>0,ρ(b)≠0,ι(b)=tic(r).i>0,\qquad \rho(b)\ne0,\qquad \iota(b)=t^i c(r).(10)✦ Let b∈Bb\in B, r∈Ar\in A and i∈ℤi\in\mathbb Z satisfy ι(b)=tic(r)\iota(b)=t^i c(r). The special fiber reduction of bb satisfies (11): ρ(b)∈Gi.\rho(b)\in G_i.(11)✦ Suppose AA is isomorphic as a CC-algebra to the polynomial ring in four variables. There are an integer ii, an element r∈Gr\in G and a locally nilpotent CC-derivation D:G→GD:G\to G satisfying (12): i>0,0≠r∈Gi,D≠0,D(r)=0.i>0,\qquad 0\ne r\in G_i,\qquad D\ne0,\qquad D(r)=0.(12)✦

In the paper, the result reads: if AA is isomorphic as a CC-algebra to the polynomial ring in four variables, then the associated graded algebra gr⁡A\operatorname{gr}A has a nonzero homogeneous locally nilpotent CC-derivation with a nonzero homogeneous invariant of strictly positive valuation degree.

What Is Checked

The statements are over the explicit quotient algebras AA, BB and GG, their quotient and evaluation maps, and the valuation components GiG_i; the hypothesis in (12) is a CC-algebra isomorphism from AA to a polynomial ring in four variables.